Alice Cooper Group (November 18, 1972) – “Alice Is Still Swinging – By the Neck” Concert Review November 10, 1972
Updated: 2 days ago
MELODY MAKER |
Chris Charlesworth reports from Green’s Playhouse, Glasgow, on the Alice Cooper Group’s November 10, 1972 concert, describing a performance built around hard rock, theatrical violence and an exceptionally vocal Scottish audience. Charlesworth follows the stage show through straitjacket, sword, staged killing and hanging sequences, while separating Alice Cooper’s theatrical character from the musicians behind the spectacle and awarding the band full marks for its musical impact. |
FEATURE HIGHLIGHTS
FEATURE | DETAILS |
Artist: | Alice Cooper Group |
Publication: | Melody Maker |
Publication Date: | November 18, 1972 |
Concert Date: | November 10, 1972 |
Venue: | Green’s Playhouse |
Location: | Glasgow, Scotland |
Writer: | Chris Charlesworth |
Headline: | Alice Is Still Swinging – By the Neck |
Photographer: | Barrie Wentzell |
Band Member Identified: | Neal Smith |
Stage Elements Documented: | Snake, sword, straitjacket, staged killing, hanging, smoke, lighting |
Format: | Concert Review |
Principal Theme: | Alice Cooper Group’s combination of hard rock, theatrical violence and intense audience reaction |
ORIGINAL SOURCE MATERIAL
PAGE 1 – OPENING REVIEW | PAGE 2 – CONTINUATION |
[MELODY MAKER, NOVEMBER 18, 1972 – “ALICE IS STILL SWINGING – BY THE NECK” OPENING PAGE] ![]() | [MELODY MAKER, NOVEMBER 18, 1972 – ALICE COOPER GROUP REVIEW CONTINUATION] ![]() |
RELATED MELODY MAKER FRONT PAGE |
![]() [MELODY MAKER, NOVEMBER 18, 1972 – ALICE COOPER GROUP FRONT-PAGE PHOTOGRAPH AND GLASGOW REPORT] |
INTRODUCTION
GREEN’S PLAYHOUSE | GLASGOW – NOVEMBER 10, 1972 |
Chris Charlesworth’s substantial Melody Maker review returns to the Alice Cooper Group’s extraordinary Green’s Playhouse appearance in Glasgow. | At the centre of the report is the collision between hard rock, carefully rehearsed shock theatre and a Scottish audience whose reaction frequently becomes part of the spectacle itself. |
ALICE IS STILL SWINGING – BY THE NECK
THE HEADLINE | THE EXECUTION SEQUENCE |
The enormous headline deliberately focuses upon one of the production’s most dramatic pieces of stage theatre. | Alice Cooper’s character ultimately reaches the gallows and is apparently hanged, providing Charlesworth with both the feature’s title and one of its central dramatic images. |
CHRIS CHARLESWORTH REPORTS
THE GLASGOW PERFORMANCE | VIOLENT ROCK |
A boxed introduction describes Charlesworth reporting as Alice Cooper brings violent rock to Glasgow. | The feature repeatedly questions the relationship between staged violence, rock performance and a city whose audience proved anything but passive. |
THE GLASGOW AUDIENCE
“ALICE, ALICE, ALICE” | A DEAFENING ROAR |
Charlesworth opens with Green’s Playhouse audiences repeatedly chanting Alice’s name. | The roar is described as intense enough for the individual words eventually to become difficult to distinguish. |
A CRY OF VIOLENCE
WHAT CHARLESWORTH HEARD | THE REVIEW’S OPENING IMAGE |
As the volume increases, Charlesworth transforms the repeated chanting into something that seems to resemble the word “violence”. | The observation gives the review its thematic starting point before the performance itself is described in detail. |
SCOTTISH ENTHUSIASM
A ROUGH SATURDAY NIGHT? | THE AUDIENCE REACTION |
Charlesworth reflects upon the reputation of Glasgow and the intensity with which local audiences responded to the concert. | The review presents the crowd as deeply involved throughout, shouting, reacting physically and embracing the theatrical mayhem occurring on stage. |
THE BAND ARRIVES
DARKNESS & ATMOSPHERE | THE SHOW BEGINS |
The performance opens with a carefully assembled atmosphere rather than simply the band walking on and beginning a song. | Smoke, stage effects and the musicians’ appearance all contribute to establishing the theatrical world before the sequence develops further. |
A VISUAL SHOCK
BLACK & WHITE | QUEERED APPEARANCES |
Charlesworth pays close attention to the group’s appearance as part of the overall effect. | Hair, clothes, make-up and stage presentation create an immediate visual identity distinct from an ordinary hard-rock performance. |
THE SNAKE
AN ESTABLISHED PROP | AROUND ALICE |
A snake is among the objects appearing during the act. | Rather than treating it as a novelty detached from the music, Charlesworth places it inside the continuing progression of shock images surrounding Alice’s character. |
THE SWORD
ANOTHER STAGE PROP | PART OF THE VIOLENCE |
A sword also enters the performance. | Its presence develops the show’s recurring pattern of threat, mock violence and apparent danger. |
DRUMMER NEAL SMITH
STABBED BY ALICE | STAGED VIOLENCE |
One photograph is captioned “DRUMMER NEIL SMITH: stabbed by Alice”. | The image and accompanying report document a mock attack forming part of the theatrical narrative rather than an actual assault. |
THE KNIFE
MOCK ATTACK | BAND MEMBER AS VICTIM |
Alice’s character uses a knife within the staged violence involving the drummer. | The incident demonstrates how members of the Alice Cooper Group became participants in the theatrical story rather than remaining musicians positioned behind the central performer. |
THE MUSIC
HARD ROCK | CHARLESWORTH APPROVES |
Beneath the violence and theatrical machinery, Charlesworth hears an extremely strong hard-rock band. | The review makes a clear distinction between possible reservations about spectacle and admiration for the music being produced. |
FULL MARKS FOR THE BAND
MUSICAL POWER | A STRONG VERDICT |
Charlesworth describes the hard-rock element in highly positive terms. | The musicians receive full marks for present, full marks for effort and full marks for stunning effect, establishing the strength of the review’s musical assessment. |
A BAND, NOT JUST A SHOCK SHOW
THE ALICE COOPER GROUP | MUSICAL SUBSTANCE |
Charlesworth’s account prevents the group from being reduced solely to snakes, swords and executions. | The musicianship is one of the concert’s key strengths and provides the hard musical foundation necessary for the theatre to work. |
THE ACT
TIMED TO PERFECTION | A REHEARSED PRODUCTION |
Charlesworth describes the act as being precisely timed. | The apparent chaos is therefore produced through careful performance rather than random onstage disorder. |
THE STRAITJACKET
ALICE IS RESTRAINED | THE NEXT STAGE OF THE STORY |
During the theatrical sequence Alice appears in a straitjacket. | The restraint becomes part of the continuing movement towards punishment and execution. |
YVONNE
THE CONSTRICTOR | SNAKE PROP |
The snake is identified in the article as Yvonne. | Alice places the constrictor around the body as one of the famous visual elements of the show. |
THE SWORD RETURNS
ALICE SWISHES THE BLADE | THE ACT CONTINUES |
A sword enters another section of the performance after the snake sequence. | Charlesworth follows each prop as part of the theatrical progression rather than treating the show as a disconnected collection of tricks. |
THE TOY GUN
DIFFERENT WEAPON | MOCK VIOLENCE CONTINUES |
A gun also becomes part of the unfolding act. | The succession of props maintains the deliberately threatening atmosphere while remaining inside the theatrical framework. |
THE GARBAGE
STAGE DEBRIS | PART OF THE SPECTACLE |
The show includes objects and debris being thrown or scattered as the violence develops. | This gives the performance a deliberately untidy, chaotic appearance despite Charlesworth’s recognition that much of the act is carefully controlled. |
THE EXECUTIONER
MASKED FIGURE | THE CHARACTER IS CONDEMNED |
The execution sequence introduces a masked figure who takes control of Alice. | The stage story progresses from threatening others to the central character becoming the victim. |
A ROPE AROUND THE NECK
THE GALLOWS | EXECUTION PREPARATION |
Alice is bound and taken towards the gallows. | The rope and execution apparatus transform the show from generalised violence into a highly specific theatrical punishment. |
THE HANGING
ALICE DANGLES | THE CENTRAL ILLUSION |
The gallows sequence culminates with Alice apparently hanging above the stage. | Charlesworth’s article title directly reflects this image, making the hanging one of the defining memories of the Glasgow show. |
THE MECHANICS OF THE ILLUSION
PIANO WIRE | STAGE TRICKERY |
Charlesworth explains that the hanging involves theatrical mechanics rather than genuine danger. | Wire and the construction of the hanging device allow the illusion to appear convincing to the audience. |
THE EXECUTIONER’S PROBLEM
STRETCHING THE ROPE | A TECHNICAL IMPERFECTION |
The article describes complications created by repeated use of the hanging sequence. | The detail is an unusual glimpse behind the apparently seamless stage illusion, revealing the practical considerations involved in performing the same execution night after night. |
THUNDER & LIGHTNING
THEATRICAL WEATHER | THE EXECUTION ATMOSPHERE |
Mock thunder and lighting effects accompany the gallows sequence. | These effects enlarge the execution into a complete dramatic scene rather than leaving the hanging as an isolated stage stunt. |
SMOKE
THE STAGE DISAPPEARS | A VISUAL TRANSITION |
Smoke floods the performance area as the theatrical sequence develops. | The stage is temporarily obscured, allowing the act to move from one image into another while maintaining dramatic tension. |
POLICE & SIRENS
MORE THEATRICAL CHAOS | AFTER THE VIOLENCE |
Police imagery and sirens enter the stage narrative as the violence escalates. | These familiar signs of authority and emergency add another layer to the show’s deliberately exaggerated criminal and punishment imagery. |
SCHOOL’S OUT
THE OPENING BARS | THE AUDIENCE REACTS |
The familiar opening of “School’s Out” provides another major moment in the concert. | Charlesworth describes the audience responding immediately, demonstrating how the musical hits and theatrical production continually feed into one another. |
THE AUDIENCE MOVES FORWARD
PHYSICAL RESPONSE | CLOSER TO THE STAGE |
As the show develops, audience members press towards the front. | The movement adds to the sense that the Glasgow crowd is participating in the event rather than simply watching from a distance. |
THE FRONT ROWS
TORCHES FLICKER | A DARKENED VENUE |
Charlesworth describes small lights appearing amongst sections of the audience. | The visual effect contributes to the concert atmosphere while the stage repeatedly moves through darkness, smoke and concentrated theatrical lighting. |
THE GROUP’S POPULARITY
THE CROWD | AN INTENSE RECEPTION |
Throughout the review, the Scottish audience’s response is treated as evidence of the Alice Cooper Group’s growing popularity. | Glasgow is presented as an especially extreme example of the intense reaction the group could provoke. |
ALICE COOPER – THE PERSONA
JEKYLL & HYDE | A STAGE CHARACTER |
Charlesworth describes Alice as possessing a Jekyll-and-Hyde quality. | The theatrical personality appearing under the lights is treated as something more extreme than the ordinary person away from the stage. |
MORE JEKYLL, LESS HYDE
OFFSTAGE | A DIFFERENT CHARACTER |
Away from the concert performance, Charlesworth suggests that the Hyde side becomes far less dominant. | This distinction helps separate the deliberately violent Alice Cooper stage character from everyday reality. |
DOES ALICE ENCOURAGE VIOLENCE?
A CENTRAL QUESTION | THE ACT & ITS AUDIENCE |
Charlesworth raises the question of whether the performance encourages violent behaviour amongst fans. | The article does not simply praise the spectacle. It actively considers the relationship between the theatrical violence and the young audience consuming it. |
ALICE’S VIEW
ENTERTAINMENT | NOT AN INSTRUCTION MANUAL |
Alice’s comments frame the violence as part of an entertainment act. | The stage character and theatrical events are presented as performance rather than encouragement for the audience to reproduce the behaviour outside the venue. |
SCOTLAND, LONDON & NEW YORK
THE ACT TRAVELS | DIFFERENT AUDIENCES |
Charlesworth places Glasgow within the wider international touring life of the Alice Cooper Group. | The same act could encounter very different audience reactions depending upon the city and circumstances surrounding the performance. |
BACK TO ENGLAND
MAY OR JUNE | A NEW ACT EXPECTED |
The article reports expectations that Alice Cooper would return to Britain the following year. | By that stage, Alice suggests the current show could be replaced by another production rather than being repeated indefinitely. |
THE SHOW KEEPS CHANGING
ONE PRODUCTION ENDS | ANOTHER WILL FOLLOW |
The Alice Cooper Group’s theatrical presentation was not intended to remain permanently fixed. | The Glasgow review therefore documents one particular version of the show at a specific moment in the group’s continuing development. |
BARRIE WENTZELL
CONCERT PHOTOGRAPHY | LARGE PERFORMANCE IMAGE |
The continuation page contains a huge monochrome performance photograph credited to Barrie Wentzell. | The image provides a dramatic visual companion to Charlesworth’s descriptions of Alice’s stage character. |
ALICE COOPER: “HANG HIM” IS THE CRY
THE PHOTOGRAPH CAPTION | THE EXECUTION THEME |
The large performance image is accompanied by the caption “ALICE COOPER: ‘Hang him’ is the cry”. | The wording connects directly with the gallows sequence that supplies the review’s headline. |
THE MELODY MAKER FRONT PAGE
ALICE COOPER GROUP PHOTOGRAPH | GLASGOW REPORT |
Melody Maker also gives the Glasgow story major front-page prominence in the November 18 issue. | A large performance photograph dominates the page alongside a report describing the reception surrounding the Green’s Playhouse concert. |
FAN HYSTERIA
THE FRONT-PAGE REPORT | GLASGOW |
The front page describes intense audience reaction surrounding the Green’s Playhouse performance. | This provides a powerful companion source to Charlesworth’s longer review, which examines the actual construction of the stage show in considerably greater detail. |
A MAJOR MELODY MAKER STORY
FRONT PAGE | MULTI-PAGE REVIEW |
The concert was important enough to generate both front-page coverage and a substantial internal feature. | Preserving the pages together reveals how heavily Melody Maker treated the Glasgow event within the November 18 issue. |
THE ALICE COOPER GROUP
THE BAND | PRE-1975 TERMINOLOGY |
This performance belongs to the original Alice Cooper Group era. | The Chronicle therefore refers to the act as the Alice Cooper Group, using Alice Cooper only when discussing the stage character or individual performer specifically described in the contemporary source. |
DOCUMENTED SONG
SONG SPECIFICALLY NAMED | NO IMPORTED SETLIST |
School’s Out | The supplied article does not print a complete Glasgow setlist, so no generic tour running order has been added. |
WHAT THE REVIEW DOCUMENTS
THE MUSIC | THE THEATRE |
Hard-rock performance Strong band musicianship “School’s Out” specifically mentioned Powerful audience response Carefully timed production | Snake Sword Knife Straitjacket Mock stabbing Police and sirens Executioner Gallows Hanging illusion Thunder, lighting and smoke |
CONTEXT AND NOTES
HISTORICAL CONTEXT | ARCHIVAL SIGNIFICANCE |
Chris Charlesworth’s review was published in Melody Maker on November 18, 1972 following the Alice Cooper Group’s November 10 appearance at Green’s Playhouse, Glasgow. | The article is one of the strongest surviving contemporary descriptions of the actual theatrical construction of the Glasgow show, moving through props, violence, staging, audience response and musical performance. |
The review does not treat the concert solely as shock theatre. Charlesworth explicitly praises the hard-rock band beneath the spectacle and gives the musicians an exceptionally strong assessment. | This balance is important to the archive because it prevents the concert from being reduced either to sensationalism or to music alone. The source documents the interaction between both. |
Melody Maker also gave the Glasgow story front-page treatment in the same November 18 issue. | Keeping the front page with Charlesworth’s detailed feature creates a more complete archive of how one publication presented the event immediately afterwards. |
Only “School’s Out” has been included as a documented song because it is specifically identifiable within the supplied pages. | A complete setlist has not been reconstructed from a neighbouring date or later tour source. This keeps the Chronicle tied to the evidence actually preserved in the original Melody Maker material. |
CONCLUSION
ALICE IS STILL SWINGING – BY THE NECK | GLASGOW AS THEATRE, ROCK & MAYHEM |
Chris Charlesworth’s review captures the Alice Cooper Group at the point where hard rock and elaborate shock theatre had become inseparable. Snake, sword, straitjacket, staged violence and the gallows might dominate the immediate visual memory, but beneath them Charlesworth hears a powerful band delivering the music with precision and force. | The Glasgow audience completes the story. Its chanting, movement and intense response turn the Green’s Playhouse performance into something larger than a rehearsed stage production. Combined with Melody Maker’s front-page coverage, the feature preserves an unusually detailed contemporary account of one of the most dramatic British appearances of the original Alice Cooper Group’s 1972 visit. |
SOURCES / COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE |
SOURCES Melody Maker November 18, 1972 Chris Charlesworth Barrie Wentzell Original supplied Melody Maker feature pages Original supplied Melody Maker front page COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE All magazine scans, newspaper cuttings, photographs and original text excerpts referenced in this entry remain the property of their respective copyright holders. This Chronicle entry is a transformative, non-commercial archival summary created for historical documentation and educational reference. No ownership of the original material is claimed or implied. |








Comments