top of page

David Bowie (October 20–21, 1972) – Santa Monica Concert Review - Melody Maker (November 11, 1972)

Nov 11, 1972
6 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

MELODY MAKER

Richard Cromelin reports from Santa Monica on David Bowie during the first American Ziggy Stardust tour. After finding the Friday performance nervous and tight, Cromelin describes the following night as devastating, praising Bowie’s voice, songwriting, stage presence and the decision to strip away distracting theatrics in favour of the songs themselves.

FEATURE HIGHLIGHTS

FEATURE

DETAILS

Artist:

David Bowie

Publication:

Melody Maker

Publication Date:

November 11, 1972

Writer:

Richard Cromelin

Location:

Santa Monica, California, USA

Venue:

Santa Monica Civic Auditorium

Performances Discussed:

Friday and Saturday concerts

Tour:

Ziggy Stardust Tour

Band:

The Spiders from Mars

Songs Mentioned:

Space Oddity, The Jean Genie

Format:

Concert Review

Principal Theme:

Bowie establishing himself as a commanding American live performer

ORIGINAL SOURCE MATERIAL

ORIGINAL MELODY MAKER CUTTING

David Bowie – Santa Monica Concert Review, Melody Maker (November 11, 1972), October 20–21, 1972 – Melody Maker, November 11, 1972 – David Bowie Santa Monica Concert Review

[MELODY MAKER, NOVEMBER 11, 1972 – DAVID BOWIE SANTA MONICA CONCERT REVIEW]

INTRODUCTION

ZIGGY PLAYED GUITAR

A STUNNING PROGRAMME

Richard Cromelin begins with a playful reference to the Ziggy Stardust lyric before settling into an emphatically favourable assessment of Bowie’s American live performance.

Cromelin describes the programme as varied, carefully constructed and ultimately stunning, arguing that the concerts confirmed Bowie as an unusually gifted and commanding new performer.

TWO NIGHTS IN SANTA MONICA

FRIDAY

SATURDAY

Cromelin describes the Friday Santa Monica performance as good but noticeably nervous and tight.

The following performance in the same hall receives a much stronger verdict. Cromelin characterises Saturday’s show as devastating, indicating a dramatic improvement from one night to the next.

A DATE POINT WORTH PRESERVING

THE REVIEW

THE SURVIVING RECORDING

Cromelin explicitly discusses performances on a Friday and the following Saturday at Santa Monica.

A surviving professional radio recording documents Bowie at Santa Monica Civic Auditorium on October 20, 1972, a Friday. That concert was recorded for a KMET FM radio broadcast and later officially released as Live Santa Monica ’72.

BOWIE’S VOICE

THE FOCAL POINT

MAXIMUM IMPACT

Cromelin regards Bowie’s singing as the central strength of the show and describes the voice as both distinctive and unusually compelling.

The reviewer praises Bowie’s understanding of how to use that voice for maximum effect, aided by what Cromelin considered an exceptionally clear public-address system.

SONGS BEFORE SPECTACLE

A DELIBERATE CHOICE

THE WRITING

Cromelin believes Bowie had recognised that his strength lay in the songs and therefore avoided allowing stage effects to distract from them.

The result, in the reviewer’s assessment, was a series of particularly strong performances of Bowie’s best material rather than a concert overwhelmed by visual gimmickry.

SPACE ODDITY TO THE JEAN GENIE

THE EARLIER CATALOGUE

NEW MATERIAL

Cromelin states that the programme stretched back to “Space Oddity”, demonstrating that Bowie was not limiting the American show to the recently created Ziggy material.

At the other end of the chronology, the reviewer identifies the forthcoming “The Jean Genie”, which was still new enough for Cromelin to joke about being unsure of its spelling.

SPACE ODDITY

A SONG FROM THE EARLIER BOWIE

PART OF THE LIVE SET

Cromelin specifically identifies “Space Oddity” as part of the historical span represented by the concert programme.

The surviving October 20 Santa Monica recording likewise documents “Space Oddity” among the songs performed during this stage of the American tour.

THE JEAN GENIE

A NEW SINGLE

LOOKING FORWARD

“The Jean Genie” is described by Cromelin as Bowie’s new single.

Its presence demonstrates that the Santa Monica concerts were not simply presenting the established Ziggy Stardust album. Bowie was already bringing newer material into the set.

THE SURVIVING OCTOBER 20 SET

FIRST HALF

SECOND HALF

Hang On to Yourself


Ziggy Stardust


Changes


The Supermen


Life on Mars?


Five Years


Space Oddity


Andy Warhol


My Death

The Width of a Circle


Queen Bitch


Moonage Daydream


John, I’m Only Dancing


Waiting for the Man


The Jean Genie


Suffragette City


Rock ’n’ Roll Suicide

This set comes from the surviving October 20 Santa Monica recording. It should not automatically be treated as proof that the following night’s running order was identical.

THE SPIDERS FROM MARS

MICK RONSON / TREVOR BOLDER

WOODY WOODMANSEY / MIKE GARSON

The surviving October 20 recording documents Mick Ronson on lead guitar and backing vocals, with Trevor Bolder on bass.

Mick “Woody” Woodmansey played drums, while Mike Garson supplied keyboards during this stage of Bowie’s American tour.

MICK RONSON

ONSTAGE INTERACTION

A RELAXED BOWIE

Cromelin describes Bowie interacting and fooling around with Ronson on stage.

That detail contributes to the writer’s rejection of an image of Bowie as remote or detached. The performer observed in Santa Monica is presented as responsive to both the musicians and audience.

NOT AN UNEARTHLY STARMAN

THE PERSON ON STAGE

THE PUBLIC IMAGE

Cromelin explicitly rejects the expectation that Bowie might come across as an unapproachable “Starman” or futuristic figure.

Instead, the writer sees a recognisably human performer who chats or chants with the audience, acknowledges applause, smiles and interacts naturally with the people around him.

CHARISMA WITHOUT FORCING IT

BEAUTY & PRESENCE

NATURAL PRESENTATION

The review recognises Bowie’s strong physical and visual presence as part of the performance.

Crucially, Cromelin believes Bowie allows that charisma to emerge without appearing to force it, making the stage identity seem much more natural than might have been expected from the Ziggy imagery.

A BROADER STYLE

SHOWBIZ NIGHTCLUB

CLASSIC MIME

Cromelin attempts to define Bowie’s style through comparisons extending beyond conventional rock performance.

The reviewer sees elements of sophisticated show-business presentation and mime within Bowie’s approach, arguing that the result is more expansive than that of a conventional rock ’n’ roll performer.

THE FIRST AMERICAN TOUR

AN ENGLISH HEADLINER

THE COMPARISON

Cromelin places considerable importance on Bowie headlining his first American tour.

The review claims that an English act had not entered an initial American tour with comparable headlining stature since the vintage period of the Beatles and the Rolling Stones. This is Cromelin’s contemporary assessment and should be preserved as such.

WHY THE REVIEW MATTERS

NOT HINDSIGHT

AN ARTIST STILL EMERGING

Cromelin was not writing from the perspective of Bowie’s later established status.

The striking element of the review is how strongly the writer recognises Bowie’s potential in real time, declaring that the artist fully deserved the prominence surrounding the first American tour.

THE FINAL VERDICT

FULLY MERITS THE HONOUR

JUST WATCH HIM NOW

Cromelin concludes that Bowie deserved the exceptional attention surrounding his American debut as a headlining performer.

The final phrase, “Just watch him now,” gives the review an especially powerful archival quality. It captures a critic identifying Bowie’s significance while the American breakthrough was still unfolding.

WHAT THE CUTTING DOCUMENTS

THE PERFORMANCE

THE CRITICAL RESPONSE

Santa Monica concerts



Ziggy Stardust Tour



The Spiders from Mars



“Space Oddity”



“The Jean Genie”



Strong vocal presentation



Reduced emphasis on distracting theatrics

Friday performance described as nervous and tight



Saturday described as devastating



Bowie praised as a commanding performer



Songwriting identified as a central strength



Natural charisma



Major expectations for Bowie’s American future

CONTEXT AND NOTES

HISTORICAL CONTEXT

ARCHIVAL SIGNIFICANCE

The surviving radio recording from Santa Monica Civic Auditorium is dated October 20, 1972, corresponding with the Friday performance discussed by Cromelin. The review also describes a second performance the following Saturday.

The cutting is particularly valuable because Cromelin directly compares the two nights. The weaker first performance provides context for the much more enthusiastic judgement of what followed, rather than the article functioning as an uncomplicated rave from beginning to end.

The complete track listing above belongs specifically to the documented October 20 recording. It has not been silently assigned to the Saturday concert because the supplied review does not establish that both nights used an identical running order.

Cromelin’s comments capture Bowie during an American breakthrough still in progress. The critic’s confidence in Bowie’s talent, voice and live presence therefore provides contemporary evidence rather than retrospective acclaim.

CONCLUSION

DAVID BOWIE IN SANTA MONICA

JUST WATCH HIM NOW

Richard Cromelin’s review documents a performer apparently developing from one night to the next. Friday is remembered as somewhat tense; Saturday becomes the devastating performance in which Bowie’s singing, songs, charisma and command of the stage come together.

The final assessment is remarkably prescient. Rather than being distracted by the mythology of Ziggy Stardust, Cromelin concentrates on the qualities underneath it and concludes that Bowie deserved his remarkable American opportunity. “Just watch him now” is an extraordinary contemporary closing line for an artist whose larger American story was only beginning.

SOURCES

SOURCE MATERIAL

ARCHIVAL VERIFICATION

Melody Maker


November 11, 1972


Richard Cromelin


Original supplied David Bowie review

Santa Monica Civic Auditorium concert documentation


October 20, 1972 radio recording


Live Santa Monica ’72

COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL NOTE

COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE

All magazine scans, photographs, recordings, record artwork and original text excerpts referenced in this entry remain the property of their respective copyright holders. This Chronicle entry is a transformative, non-commercial archival summary created for historical documentation and educational reference. No ownership of the original material is claimed or implied.


Comments


bottom of page