top of page

Mott The Hoople (November 4, 1972) – “Rock And Roll Raunchy Mott” All The Young Dudes Album Review - Record Mirror

Nov 4, 1972
6 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

RECORD MIRROR

Published in the November 4, 1972 edition of Record Mirror, “Rock And Roll Raunchy Mott” reviews Mott The Hoople’s All The Young Dudes as the group moves decisively towards a more direct rock ’n’ roll approach. The review acknowledges the band’s earlier reputation for sprawling or less focused material before finding considerably more to admire in the new album. Particular attention is given to the strength of the songwriting, Ian Hunter’s performance and the way the record brings together tough rock arrangements with more melodic passages.

FEATURE HIGHLIGHTS

FEATURE

DETAILS

Artist:

Mott The Hoople

Publication:

Record Mirror

Date:

November 4, 1972

Page:

20

Section:

Mirrorpick / LPs

Headline:

“Rock And Roll Raunchy Mott”

Album:

All The Young Dudes

Catalogue:

CBS 65184

Format:

Album review within full-page LP reviews

Principal Theme:

Mott The Hoople’s move towards direct rock ’n’ roll

ORIGINAL SOURCE MATERIAL

ORIGINAL RECORD MIRROR ALL THE YOUNG DUDES ALBUM REVIEW

Mott The Hoople – “Rock And Roll Raunchy Mott” All The Young Dudes Album Review, Record Mirror, November 4, 1972

[IMAGE – RECORD MIRROR, NOVEMBER 4, 1972 – MOTT THE HOOPLE / “ROCK AND ROLL RAUNCHY MOTT”]

INTRODUCTION

The review is especially useful because it catches All The Young Dudes as a current release rather than approaching the album through its later reputation. The title track is clearly important, but the writer does not reduce the record to one song.

Instead, tracks including “Sweet Jane,” “Momma’s Little Jewel,” “Jerkin’ Crocus,” “Sucker,” “One Of The Boys” and “Ready For Love/After Lights” are considered as part of an album the reviewer ultimately judges to contain more consistent and convincing material than the group’s earlier work.

ROCK AND ROLL RAUNCHY MOTT

THE NEW APPROACH

THE RESULT

The headline makes the reviewer’s central impression immediately clear: this is Mott The Hoople as a forceful rock ’n’ roll band. The record is praised for concentrating the group’s strengths into material that feels more direct and accessible.

That greater focus produces an album the reviewer regards as substantially stronger than the more uneven work associated with the group previously. The arrangements retain roughness and energy without losing melodic character.

The band’s musical identity is not presented as completely reinvented, but as newly concentrated.

The result is a record in which the individual songs stand out more clearly while still sounding recognisably like Mott The Hoople.

ALL THE YOUNG DUDES

THE TITLE TRACK

THE ALBUM

“All The Young Dudes” is one of the obvious focal points, with the song’s strength contributing significantly to the album’s overall impact.

The reviewer nevertheless treats the LP as considerably more than a vehicle for its best-known song. Other tracks provide enough variety and quality to sustain the complete record.

The song brings a strong melodic component to the group’s rock sound.

Across the album, the harder material is balanced by more reflective and melodic moments.

THE SONGS

TRACKS HIGHLIGHTED

REVIEW CHARACTER

Sweet Jane, Momma’s Little Jewel, All The Young Dudes, Sucker, Jerkin’ Crocus, One Of The Boys and Ready For Love/After Lights are among the songs discussed in the review.

The writer moves through individual songs to demonstrate the record’s variety rather than simply offering a general judgement. The balance of harder rockers and contrasting passages becomes part of the album’s appeal.

Several tracks are praised for combining strong melodies with the rougher musical personality associated with the group.

The cumulative impression is of an album whose songs are substantially more memorable and effective than the reviewer expected from previous experience of Mott The Hoople.

IAN HUNTER

VOCALS & SONGS

GROUP IDENTITY

Ian Hunter’s singing and writing receive particular attention. The review presents Hunter as central to the character of the album, with the vocal delivery helping hold together material that ranges from straightforward rock ’n’ roll to more melodic writing.

Hunter’s presence provides continuity across the album even when individual songs move in different directions. The rough-edged vocal identity helps prevent the more polished moments from losing the group’s established personality.

THE BAND

MUSICAL FORCE

MELODIC RANGE

The album’s tougher passages allow Mott The Hoople to operate as the loud, energetic rock band suggested by the review’s headline. Guitar and rhythm-section power are fundamental to the record’s impact.

The reviewer also responds to subtler passages, noting enough variation to prevent the album from becoming one-dimensional. That combination of force and melody is one of the reasons the record receives such a favourable assessment.

READY FOR LOVE

THE SONG

THE EFFECT

“Ready For Love/After Lights” is among the material singled out within the review, contributing a different texture from the album’s most direct rock numbers.

Its inclusion reinforces the reviewer’s point that All The Young Dudes possesses greater range than a description such as “raunchy rock ’n’ roll” might initially suggest.

THE COVER

VISUAL PRESENTATION

REVIEW COMMENT

The album sleeve is also noticed within the column, demonstrating that the reviewer is responding to the complete physical LP rather than simply the recorded programme.

Comments on the cover contribute another small detail to the contemporary reception of the album, preserving how All The Young Dudes was encountered as a new record in 1972.

OTHER ALBUMS ON THE PAGE

LEFT / CENTRE REVIEWS

RIGHT-HAND REVIEWS

The full Mirrorpick/LPs page also reviews releases by Natural Acoustic Band, Stoney and Meatloaf, Peter D. Kelly, Jonesey, George Hamilton IV, Jerry Reed and Chet Atkins, Otis Redding, Jerry Lee Lewis, Original Artists, Hank Crawford and Ike & Tina Turner.

Additional columns cover Hunt and Turner, Diana Ross, Tucker Zimmerman, The Incredible String Band, Tight Like That, Daye Evans, Charlie Mingus, Hank Snow, Jerry Reed, The Modern Jazz Quartet, Bob Seger, Various Artists, Davy Newman and Billy Cotton and his Orchestra.

Mott The Hoople receive the largest individual review and a prominent photograph.

The complete page demonstrates the breadth of LP material reviewed together in a single weekly section.

THE MIRRORPICK PAGE

EDITORIAL PRESENTATION

ARCHIVAL VALUE

The Mott The Hoople review occupies the dominant upper-left area beneath the large “Rock and Roll raunchy Mott” headline. A substantial monochrome group photograph reinforces the prominence of the review compared with many of the smaller columns surrounding it.

Keeping the complete page preserves the original editorial hierarchy. Mott The Hoople were not reviewed in isolation: All The Young Dudes appeared alongside country, soul, jazz, folk and rock releases, showing how widely Record Mirror’s LP coverage ranged within a single issue.

CONTEXT AND NOTES

1972 CONTEXT

ARCHIVAL SIGNIFICANCE

All The Young Dudes is treated as a current album whose longer-term reputation had not yet been established. The reviewer approaches Mott The Hoople with reservations based on earlier material, making the favourable response to the new record particularly significant within the piece itself.

The review preserves the immediate impact of hearing the album without decades of retrospective acclaim. The writer identifies greater focus, stronger songs and a convincing balance between force and melody, allowing the cutting to document exactly what seemed improved about Mott The Hoople at that moment.

The page also demonstrates the position of rock albums within an eclectic record-review environment that readily placed them beside jazz, country, soul and acoustic releases.

The physical page is therefore useful both as a Mott The Hoople review and as an example of how British weekly music papers presented new LPs in 1972.

CONCLUSION

THE REVIEW IN RETROSPECT

ARCHIVAL SIGNIFICANCE

“Rock And Roll Raunchy Mott” is strongly positive without pretending that the reviewer had always been convinced by the group. That earlier scepticism makes the response to All The Young Dudes more meaningful: the album is judged to have given Mott The Hoople stronger material, greater focus and enough melodic range to complement the band’s natural rock ’n’ roll force.

For the archive, the cutting captures All The Young Dudes at the moment listeners and critics were first deciding what kind of album it was. The title track inevitably commands attention, but the review’s real value is its recognition that the surrounding songs turn the LP into a convincing complete record rather than merely a successful single surrounded by lesser material.

FEATURE

DETAILS

Artist:

Slade

Publication:

New Musical Express

Date:

November 4, 1972

Page:

18

Interviewer:

Elizabeth Walker

Headline:

“Back From The Badlands”

Principal Subject:

Don Powell

Format:

Full-page interview / feature

Principal Theme:

American touring, audiences and the forthcoming Slade album

SOURCES / COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE

SOURCES

Record Mirror, November 4, 1972, page 20.Mirrorpick/LPs.


COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE

All magazine scans, newspaper cuttings, photographs, and original text excerpts referenced in this entry remain the property of their respective copyright holders. This Chronicle entry is a transformative, non-commercial archival summary created for historical documentation and educational reference. No ownership of the original material is claimed or implied. All magazine scans, newspaper cuttings, photographs, and original text excerpts referenced in this entry remain the property of their respective copyright holders. This Chronicle entry is a transformative, non-commercial archival summary created for historical documentation and educational reference. No ownership of the original material is claimed or implied.


Comments


bottom of page