Slade (November 30, 1972) – “‘Slade Alive’: Real Wild, The Louder The Better” Album Review - Portland Press Herald
PORTLAND PRESS HERALD |
Published in the Portland Press Herald on November 30, 1972, this enthusiastic American review places Slade Alive! firmly within the raw, high-volume rock tradition that critic Robert Hilburn believed the group represented so effectively. Writing in the newspaper’s Pop Records column, Hilburn acknowledges that Slade owed an obvious debt to earlier rock acts, specifically mentioning Led Zeppelin, Humble Pie and The Rolling Stones, but argues that the group nevertheless possessed enough irrepressible rock ’n’ roll energy to make the album work emphatically on its own terms. The comparison Hilburn reaches for is striking: the best moments of Slade Alive! are placed alongside the excitement of Exile on Main St. |
FEATURE HIGHLIGHTS
FEATURE | DETAILS |
Artist: | Slade |
Album: |
|
Publication: | Portland Press Herald |
Type: | Live Album |
Date: | November 30, 1972 |
Section: | Pop Records |
Location: | Portland, Maine |
Format Discussed: | Two-sided LP |
Writer: |
|
Focus: | Energy, volume and performance |
Credit: | Los Angeles Times |
Current Single Mentioned: | Mama Weer All Crazee Now |
ORIGINAL SOURCE MATERIAL
ORIGINAL PORTLAND PRESS HERALD ALBUM REVIEW |
![]() [PORTLAND PRESS HERALD, NOVEMBER 30, 1972 – SLADE / “‘SLADE ALIVE’: REAL WILD, THE LOUDER THE BETTER”] |
INTRODUCTION
The article also captures an important moment in Slade’s attempt to translate enormous British success into recognition in the United States. Hilburn notes the group’s extraordinary run of British hit singles and reports that Slade Alive! had remained high in the English Top 10 for months. The principal recommendation is wonderfully direct: this is an album that benefits from being played loudly. | Hilburn works through the record’s mixture of covers and originals, praising the opening rush and reserving particular enthusiasm for the second side and “Get Down and Get With It.” The review closes by pointing towards “Mama Weer All Crazee Now,” describing the single as evidence that American listeners could expect considerably more from Slade. |
THE REVIEW
THE ALBUM | HILBURN’S VERDICT |
Slade Alive! is presented as forceful, direct rock ’n’ roll. | The louder the album is played, the better it sounds. |
The record combines Slade originals with interpretations of earlier rock material. | The group’s energy outweighs concerns about musical imitation. |
The first side begins at a frantic pace. | Side two is described as the decisive part of the record. |
Audience energy and live performance are fundamental to the album’s identity. | Hilburn closes by predicting considerable future rock pleasure from Slade. |
Hilburn begins with criticism rather than unqualified praise. The review describes a “rather shameless quality of imitation and downright thievery” within Slade’s music, naming Led Zeppelin, Humble Pie and the Rolling Stones among the principal influences. | But the criticism immediately leads into the reason Hilburn believes the record succeeds anyway. Slade possess what the reviewer calls some of the most “potent, irresistible rock ’n’ roll” available that year. |
THE LOUDER THE BETTER
QUALITY | EFFECT |
High volume | Strengthens the album’s impact |
Raw rock ’n’ roll | Gives the recording immediacy |
Live atmosphere | Contributes to the energy |
Direct arrangements | Keeps the record moving |
Vigorous performance | Makes Slade’s familiarity with earlier rock less important |
Hilburn’s recommendation is simple: “Slade Alive sounds better the louder you play it.” That line effectively summarises the entire review. Subtlety and complexity are not presented as the album’s virtues. | The attraction lies in force, enthusiasm and the physical excitement of the performance. |
BRITISH SUCCESS
ENGLAND | AMERICAN PROSPECTS |
Slade had produced a continuing run of British hit singles. | The group was still seeking comparable US exposure. |
Slade Alive! had remained high in the English Top 10 for months. | Hilburn believes additional exposure could repeat some of that success in America. |
The British press had already devoted significant attention to the group. | The album is presented as a strong introduction for American listeners. |
Slade were already a major British attraction. | Hilburn expects the group’s profile to grow. |
The review emphasises the contrast between Slade’s established British popularity and their still-developing American position. | For American readers encountering the group in 1972, Hilburn effectively presents Slade Alive! as evidence explaining why Britain had already responded so strongly. |
THE BOLAN COMPARISON
The article contains a particularly interesting contemporary comparison involving Marc Bolan. | Hilburn quotes a Melody Maker observation suggesting: “If (Marc) Bolan with his impish appeal is the successor to the Beatles, then Slade is the antihero successor to the Stones.” |
MARC BOLAN / T. REX | SLADE |
“Impish appeal” | Antihero image |
Compared with the Beatles | Compared with the Rolling Stones |
Pop-idol charisma | Rougher rock presentation |
Different route to mass popularity | Hard-driving live energy |
The comparison is useful because it places two of Britain’s biggest contemporary acts within distinctly different traditions rather than treating the emerging glam-rock audience as a single uniform movement. |
SIDE ONE
MATERIAL MENTIONED | REVIEW RESPONSE |
Hear Me Calling | Part of the frantic opening |
In Like A Shot From My Gun | Continues the early momentum |
Darling, Be Home Soon | Provides a slower section |
Know Who You Are | Energy begins rebuilding |
Hilburn describes the beginning of the album as a frenzy, highlighting the back-to-back impact of “Hear Me Calling” and “In Like A Shot From My Gun.” | The pace drops with John Sebastian’s “Darling, Be Home Soon,” before the album starts to rebuild its momentum. |
SIDE TWO
SONG / ELEMENT | ASSESSMENT |
Keep On Rocking | Rousing tribute to Chuck Berry and Little Richard |
Get Down and Get With It | Album highlight |
Overall side | Described as the clincher |
Rock energy | Maintained at a high level |
For Hilburn, side two is where Slade Alive! becomes particularly convincing. | It opens with the group’s energetic interpretation of the rock ’n’ roll tradition before moving towards what the reviewer identifies as the album’s finest moment. |
GET DOWN AND GET WITH IT
The strongest individual praise is reserved for: “Get Down and Get With It.” | Hilburn describes the performance as a “whirlwind of rock energy.” |
MUSICAL QUALITY | REVIEWER RESPONSE |
High-energy performance | Major album highlight |
Strong live character | Captures Slade’s principal appeal |
Rock ’n’ roll directness | Presented as exciting rather than sophisticated |
Maximum volume | Central to the recommended listening experience |
The song becomes the clearest example of what Hilburn values about Slade. | The group does not need musical mystery or complexity when the performance generates this degree of momentum. |
NOTHING MYSTERIOUS
Hilburn states plainly that there is nothing especially innovative, complex or mysterious about Slade’s music. |
NOT THE APPEAL | THE REAL APPEAL |
Complexity | Energy |
Mystery | Directness |
Innovation for its own sake | Rock ’n’ roll enthusiasm |
Musical refinement | Physical excitement |
Subtlety | Force |
This is not intended entirely as criticism. The reviewer argues that Slade’s forceful, celebratory nature is strong enough to overcome those limitations. | The band understands the type of music it wants to make and attacks it without hesitation. |
MAMA WEER ALL CRAZEE NOW
The article concludes by turning from the album towards Slade’s new single: | “Mama Weer All Crazee Now.” |
BRITISH POSITION | US DEVELOPMENT |
Already a No. 1 record in England | Newly appearing on US sales charts |
Established Slade hit | Evidence of growing American attention |
Continues the group’s successful run | Hilburn believes it is as appealing as the album material |
The reviewer sees the single as evidence that the story will continue beyond Slade Alive!. | Hilburn concludes that listeners could look forward to “a lot of rock pleasure from Slade in the coming months.” |
COMPARISONS & INFLUENCES
ARTIST | CONTEXT IN REVIEW |
Led Zeppelin | Cited as an influence |
Humble Pie | Cited as an influence |
Rolling Stones | Major comparison |
Marc Bolan / T. Rex | Contemporary British comparison |
Beatles | Used within Bolan comparison |
John Sebastian | Songwriting credit discussed |
Chuck Berry | Rock ’n’ roll tribute |
Little Richard | Rock ’n’ roll tribute |
The number of comparisons demonstrates how Hilburn attempts to explain Slade to an American newspaper audience through already familiar musical reference points. | At the same time, the reviewer ultimately argues that the group possesses enough energy and personality to transcend the influences. |
CONTEXT AND NOTES
SLADE IN 1972 | ARCHIVAL SIGNIFICANCE |
Major British chart success | Contemporary American album assessment |
Highly successful singles | Documents developing US awareness |
Slade Alive! established in UK charts | Records American critical response |
Mama Weer All Crazee Now already No. 1 in Britain | Captures the single entering US awareness |
British press interest substantial | Places Slade beside Bolan, Stones and other rock reference points |
The review is particularly valuable because it captures Slade at the point when American critics were deciding how to interpret a group already enormously successful in Britain. | Hilburn does not pretend the band is musically unprecedented. Instead, the argument is almost the reverse: Slade openly draw on familiar rock traditions, but perform with sufficient power and enthusiasm to make those influences secondary to the experience of the album itself. |
AT A GLANCE
FEATURE | DETAILS |
Artist: | Slade |
Album: | Slade Alive! |
Headline: | “‘Slade Alive’: Real Wild, The Louder The Better” |
Publication: | Portland Press Herald |
Date: | November 30, 1972 |
Writer: | Robert Hilburn |
Section: | Pop Records |
Album Highlight: | Get Down and Get With It |
Current Single: | Mama Weer All Crazee Now |
Overall Verdict: | Raw, forceful and best played loud |
WHAT THE REVIEW SHOWS
THE ALBUM | THE WIDER PICTURE |
Slade Alive! praised for energy | Slade already hugely successful in Britain |
Side two receives strongest approval | American recognition still developing |
Get Down and Get With It highlighted | Marc Bolan comparison reflects the contemporary UK scene |
Influences openly acknowledged | Earlier rock acts provide context for US readers |
High volume recommended | Mama Weer All Crazee Now indicates further momentum |
Simplicity treated as part of the appeal | Hilburn expects Slade’s American profile to increase |
The review succeeds because Hilburn does not try to make Slade Alive! into something it is not. The album is judged as a loud, direct and exuberant rock ’n’ roll record, and on those terms the verdict is emphatically favourable. | For the Slade archive, it provides an excellent contemporary American perspective on the band just as their extraordinary British success was beginning to demand attention across the Atlantic. |
SOURCES / COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE |
SOURCES Portland Press Herald November 30, 1972 Original supplied Album Review scan COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE All magazine scans, newspaper cuttings, photographs, and original text excerpts referenced in this entry remain the property of their respective copyright holders. This Chronicle entry is a transformative, non-commercial archival summary created for historical documentation and educational reference. No ownership of the original material is claimed or implied. |






Comments