top of page

Zal Cleminson / SAHB (November 12, 1977) – “Cleminson Slams ‘Saboteur’ Alex” News

Nov 12, 1977
6 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

NME

Following Alex Harvey’s decision to retire from the rock business, Zal Cleminson responds with an unusually blunt public statement accusing the former SAHB frontman of disloyalty and of having “sabotaged a great band”. NME then puts Cleminson’s allegations directly to Harvey, turning the short news report into a revealing exchange about the breakdown of the Sensational Alex Harvey Band.

FEATURE

DETAILS

Principal Artist:

Zal Cleminson

Group:

The Sensational Alex Harvey Band

Publication:

New Musical Express

Publication Date:

November 12, 1977

Headline:

Cleminson slams ‘saboteur’ Alex

Other Principal Figure:

Alex Harvey

Recent Album Mentioned:

Rock Drill

Cleminson’s Plan:

Form a new band

Target for New Band:

Ready to tour by January

Format:

News / Public Dispute

Principal Theme:

Cleminson’s angry response to Harvey’s departure from SAHB

ORIGINAL SOURCE MATERIAL

ORIGINAL NME PAGE

Zal Cleminson / SAHB – “Cleminson Slams ‘Saboteur’ Alex” News, November 12, 1977 – Nme, November 12, 1977 – “cleminson Slams ‘saboteur’ Alex”

[NME, NOVEMBER 12, 1977 – “CLEMINSON SLAMS ‘SABOTEUR’ ALEX”]

INTRODUCTION

A BAND IN CRISIS

CLEMINSON SPEAKS OUT

NME reports that Alex Harvey had decided to retire from the rock business, leaving the future of the Sensational Alex Harvey Band uncertain.

Zal Cleminson, guitarist and vocalist with the group, responds publicly and forcefully. His statement makes clear how deeply Harvey’s decision had affected the musicians left behind.

CLEMINSON SLAMS ‘SABOTEUR’ ALEX

DISLOYALTY

SABOTAGE

NME frames the story around Cleminson’s accusation that Harvey had shown disloyalty to the other musicians.

Cleminson goes considerably further, arguing that Harvey had effectively “sabotaged a great band” by leaving.

A SHOCK TO THE BAND

CLEMINSON’S VERSION

THE OTHER MUSICIANS

Cleminson stresses the scale of the shock caused by Harvey’s decision.

His statement is presented not simply as a personal grievance but as a reaction to what Cleminson believed Harvey’s departure had done to the entire group.

ROCK DRILL

THE RECENT ALBUM

CLEMINSON’S ASSESSMENT

Cleminson points to the recently completed Rock Drill while explaining his anger at the timing of Harvey’s departure.

Cleminson considers it the best album the band had made to that point, making the apparent collapse of the line-up seem particularly frustrating from Cleminson’s perspective.

FIVE YEARS WITH ALEX

ADMIRATION

A BITTER ENDING

Cleminson reflects on having worked with Harvey for five years.

Despite the anger running through the statement, Cleminson acknowledges Harvey’s importance to his development as a performer and the things learnt during their years together.

WHERE’S THE IDEALISM NOW?

A PERSONAL DISAPPOINTMENT

MORE THAN BUSINESS

Cleminson questions what had happened to the idealism once associated with Harvey.

That criticism gives the disagreement a more personal dimension. Cleminson is challenging principles and loyalty rather than arguing only about the commercial future of the band.

THE PREVIOUS TWELVE MONTHS

MUSICAL FRUSTRATION

CLEMINSON WANTED MORE

Cleminson characterises the preceding year as a frustrating period musically.

The guitarist makes clear a desire to play electric music and move towards a situation offering greater creative satisfaction.

THE REHEARSAL WALKOUT

HARVEY’S DECISION

THE AFTERMATH

Cleminson describes Harvey deciding to retire during a rehearsal and walking away from the situation.

Cleminson’s anger is intensified by a belief that Harvey had subsequently failed to provide the other musicians with an adequate explanation.

LOYALTY

THE CENTRAL COMPLAINT

A BROKEN WORKING RELATIONSHIP

Loyalty becomes one of the strongest recurring themes within Cleminson’s statement.

The guitarist’s frustration concerns not merely the fact that Harvey wanted to leave, but the way Cleminson believed that decision had been handled.

NME CONTACTS ALEX HARVEY

THE RIGHT OF REPLY

HARVEY HEARS THE ACCUSATIONS

NME does not leave the story as a one-sided statement from Cleminson.

The newspaper contacts Harvey, presents Cleminson’s allegations and gives the former SAHB frontman an opportunity to respond directly.

HARVEY CHALLENGES CLEMINSON

SUDDEN SHOCK?

RETIRED A YEAR AGO?

Harvey questions an apparent contradiction in Cleminson’s account.

If Harvey’s departure was such a sudden shock, Harvey asks how Cleminson can simultaneously argue that Harvey had effectively retired a year earlier.

ROCK DRILL – ANOTHER CONTRADICTION

THE BEST ALBUM?

A FRUSTRATING YEAR?

Harvey also questions Cleminson’s exceptionally positive assessment of Rock Drill.

Harvey asks how the record could represent the band’s finest work if the preceding period had genuinely been as musically frustrating as Cleminson claimed.

HARVEY WANTED TO MOVE ON

A PERSONAL DECISION

THE EXISTING SITUATION

Harvey explains the departure through a desire to move forward.

From Harvey’s perspective, achieving that movement had become impossible within the circumstances surrounding SAHB.

NO COMPLAINTS ABOUT THE BAND

HARVEY’S POSITION

THE MUSICIANS

Harvey insists that the decision should not be interpreted as a rejection of the musicians themselves.

Rather than attacking the rest of SAHB, Harvey says there are no complaints about the band and expresses continuing support for the musicians.

NO PUBLIC SLANGING MATCH

REFUSING TO ESCALATE

WISHING THEM LUCK

Harvey declines to turn the disagreement into a prolonged exchange of insults.

The response emphasises that a public slanging match would achieve little and that Harvey genuinely wished the remaining musicians well.

TOO DEPENDENT ON ALEX

HARVEY’S VIEW

“LIKE I WAS SPIDER-MAN”

Harvey suggests that one underlying difficulty was the degree to which the other musicians depended upon the frontman.

The colourful comparison with being treated “like I was Spider-Man” illustrates Harvey’s perception that too much responsibility had been centred upon one person.

CLEMINSON LOOKS FORWARD

A NEW BAND

JANUARY

Cleminson’s statement does not end solely with anger about the past.

The guitarist announces plans to form a new group and hopes to have the project ready to go on the road by January.

CONTROL OF HIS OWN FUTURE

THE MUSIC CLEMINSON WANTED

A NEW BEGINNING

Cleminson presents the proposed group as an opportunity to play music on his own terms.

Equally important is the stated desire to control his own future rather than remain dependent upon decisions made elsewhere.

THE OTHER SAHB MEMBERS

POSSIBLE INVOLVEMENT

NOT YET CONFIRMED

The contemporary report suggests that other remaining SAHB musicians were likely to become involved in Cleminson’s new venture.

At the time of publication this remained a likely development rather than a confirmed final line-up, and that uncertainty should remain part of the historical record.

ZAL CLEMINSON

GUITARIST

FRONT-MAN ROLE

Cleminson had been a central musical and visual component of SAHB throughout the group’s established period.

With Harvey departing, the NME report presents Cleminson as the musician preparing to take greater responsibility for what might follow.

FROM TEAR GAS TO SAHB

THE EARLIER BAND

THE HARVEY YEARS

Several musicians who became associated with SAHB had previously played together in Tear Gas.

The arrival of Harvey produced the Sensational Alex Harvey Band identity and the distinctive combination of hard rock and theatrical performance increasingly associated with the group.

THE PHOTOGRAPH

ZAL CLEMINSON

CENTRAL TO THE STORY

A small monochrome portrait of Cleminson accompanies the article.

Its placement reinforces the editorial focus: although Harvey’s departure triggers the story, Cleminson’s reaction is the principal subject of the cutting.

WHY CLEMINSON HEADS THIS CHRONICLE

THE ACCUSATION

THE FUTURE

Cleminson provides the statement around which the entire article is constructed: shock, disloyalty, sabotage, musical frustration and disappointment at Harvey’s departure.

Cleminson also supplies the story’s forward movement through plans for a new band, a January touring target and a determination to gain greater control over his musical direction.

TWO SIDES OF THE BREAKDOWN

CLEMINSON

HARVEY

Cleminson sees a disloyal departure that had damaged a band still capable of making important music.

Harvey sees a situation from which it had become necessary to move on and rejects the claim that leaving amounted to deliberately sabotaging the other musicians.

WHAT THE CUTTING DOCUMENTS

CLEMINSON’S POSITION

HARVEY’S RESPONSE

Shock at Harvey’s retirement



Accusation of disloyalty



Accusation of sabotaging SAHB



Rock Drill praised



Previous year described as frustrating



Plans for a new group



January touring target



Desire for greater control

Challenges contradictions in Cleminson’s statement



Need to move forward



No complaints about the musicians



Rejects a public slanging match



Belief that too much depended upon Harvey



Wishes the remaining musicians well

CONTEXT AND NOTES

HISTORICAL CONTEXT

ARCHIVAL SIGNIFICANCE

The NME report appeared on November 12, 1977, while the future of SAHB remained unsettled following Alex Harvey’s decision to retire. It preserves Cleminson’s reaction at the point when the consequences of that decision were still unfolding.

The article is particularly valuable because NME seeks out Harvey’s response rather than publishing Cleminson’s accusations alone. The reader is therefore given two sharply different interpretations of the same breakdown.

Cleminson intended to form another group and hoped to be touring by January. The article suggests that other SAHB musicians might be involved, but does not establish a definitive future line-up.

Preserving that uncertainty is important. This is contemporary news, not a retrospective reconstruction in which the eventual outcome can be imposed upon what the musicians knew at the time.

The bitterness of Cleminson’s statement should remain intact rather than being softened in retrospect.

For the archive, uncomfortable contemporary evidence is as important as celebratory material. The disagreement helps document the human and creative pressures surrounding the end of this phase of SAHB.

CONCLUSION

CLEMINSON SLAMS ‘SABOTEUR’ ALEX

SAHB AT A BREAKING POINT

Cleminson’s November 1977 statement is unusually raw. Admiration for what Harvey had taught him sits beside allegations of disloyalty, frustration and the belief that a great band had been sabotaged just as Cleminson considered it capable of producing its strongest work.

NME’s decision to put those charges directly to Harvey makes the cutting much more valuable than a one-sided grievance. The article preserves SAHB at a genuine breaking point, while Cleminson is already attempting to turn that collapse into a new beginning under greater control of his own musical future.

SOURCES / COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE

SOURCES

New Musical Express

November 12, 1977

Original supplied NME page

Contemporary SAHB documentation


COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE

All magazine scans, photographs and original text excerpts referenced in this entry remain the property of their respective copyright holders. This Chronicle entry is a transformative, non-commercial archival summary created for historical documentation and educational reference. No ownership of the original material is claimed or implied.


Comments


bottom of page