top of page

Alice Cooper Group (November 7, 1971) – “Alice’s Moving Performance” - (November 13, 1971)

Nov 13, 1971
6 min read

MELODY MAKER

Chris Welch delivers a deliberately scathing assessment of the Alice Cooper Group’s November 7 performance at London’s Rainbow Theatre. While acknowledging the energy of the playing, an excellent light show and the audience’s enthusiastic reaction, Welch rejects the snakes, straitjacket and theatrical spectacle as hollow packaging, concluding with one of the harshest contemporary descriptions of the original group’s early British stage show.

FEATURE HIGHLIGHTS

FEATURE

DETAILS

Artist:

Alice Cooper Group

Publication:

Melody Maker

Publication Date:

November 13, 1971

Concert Date:

November 7, 1971

Venue:

Rainbow Theatre

Location:

London, England

Writer:

Chris Welch

Section:

Caught in the Act

Headline:

Alice’s Moving Performance

Support:

Arthur Brown’s Kingdom Come

Opening Presentation:

Roger Spear and his Kinetic Wardrobe

Stage Elements Mentioned:

Snake / straitjacket

Format:

Concert Review

Principal Theme:

A highly critical contemporary assessment of the Alice Cooper Group’s theatrical presentation

The original review is documented as Chris Welch’s “Caught In The Act”, published by Melody Maker on November 13, 1971. The reviewed Rainbow Theatre concert took place on November 7, 1971.

ORIGINAL SOURCE MATERIAL

ORIGINAL MELODY MAKER CONCERT REVIEW

Alice Cooper Group – “Alice’s Moving Performance”, Chris Welch concert review cutting, Melody Maker, November 13, 1971

[IMAGE – MELODY MAKER, NOVEMBER 13, 1971 – “ALICE’S MOVING PERFORMANCE”]

INTRODUCTION

CAUGHT IN THE ACT

AN UNCOMPROMISING REVIEW

Chris Welch opens with deliberately sarcastic praise, describing the Alice Cooper Group’s Rainbow Theatre appearance as a particularly “moving” performance.

The joke is immediately explained: the show made the reviewer want to leave the theatre, the rock business and the country. The tone for everything that follows is unmistakable.

THE RAINBOW THEATRE

NOVEMBER 7, 1971

LONDON

The performance took place at London’s Rainbow Theatre on Sunday, November 7, 1971.

The contemporary concert advertising billed the Alice Cooper Group alongside Arthur Brown’s Kingdom Come at the Rainbow, with an 8 p.m. start.

THE FOUNTAIN IN THE FOYER

WELCH’S OPENING VERDICT

NO ATTEMPT AT DIPLOMACY

Welch’s introduction escalates the sarcasm by describing retreat to a conveniently positioned fountain in the theatre foyer.

The deliberately grotesque image makes clear that the reader is not about to encounter a conventional, politely negative concert review.

THE BAND ACHIEVES ITS OBJECTIVE

AUDIENCE REACTION

THE CRITIC’S REACTION

Welch concedes that the Alice Cooper Group undeniably achieved one important objective: provoking a reaction from the audience.

The difficulty for Welch is that the personal reaction was overwhelmingly negative, moving from limited interest through boredom and ultimately resentment.

ARTHUR BROWN

A POINT OF COMPARISON

THEATRICAL ROCK

Welch invokes Arthur Brown when describing the extraordinary reaction the Alice Cooper Group generated.

The comparison is pertinent because Brown was himself associated with theatrical rock performance and appeared on the same Rainbow bill with Kingdom Come.

SNAKES & STRAITJACKETS

PART OF THE ACT

WELCH’S OBJECTION

The review explicitly references the snakes and straitjacket associated with the Alice Cooper stage presentation.

Welch interprets those devices not as enhancements to the rock performance but as distractions from what the reviewer wanted from the music.

THE ALICE COOPER GROUP

MUSIC & THEATRE

THE TARGETS OF THE ACT

Welch describes the band as combining rock music with deliberately provocative theatrical mockery.

The review interprets the performance as targeting rock music itself alongside subjects including mental illness and sex.

A MOMENT OF CONVERSION

THE LIGHT SHOW

THE ENERGY OF THE BAND

Despite the hostility of the review, Welch does identify a moment when the concert started to work.

The excellent lighting and the energy generated by the musicians temporarily convince the reviewer that the Alice Cooper Group might embody an archetypal American rock band.

THE HYPNOTIC BEAT

ROCK ’N’ ROLL POWER

A FLASH OF ENTHUSIASM

Welch acknowledges the hypnotic force of the group’s beat.

For a brief period, the basic energy of the music breaks through the reviewer’s objections to the surrounding theatre.

THE STRAITJACKET SEQUENCE

ALICE COOPER

THE REVIEWER’S PATIENCE ENDS

The moment of musical enthusiasm does not last once the theatrical presentation returns to the foreground.

Watching the stage character in the straitjacket pushes Welch back towards outright rejection of the performance.

THE AUDIENCE DISAGREES

THE RAINBOW COMES ALIVE

DANCING AT THE FRONT

Whatever Welch thought of the show, the audience experienced something very different.

People moved towards the front, danced, clapped and responded enthusiastically, dispelling what the reviewer had regarded as a previously flat atmosphere.

THE SNAKE

A DEFINING PROP

PART OF THE ESTABLISHED SHOW

Welch again mentions the snake when describing the audience response and the theatrical presentation.

By this stage, the reptile was not an incidental addition but one of the most immediately identifiable elements of the Alice Cooper Group’s performance imagery.

ROGER SPEAR

THE OPENING PRESENTATION

KINETIC WARDROBE

The evening began with Roger Spear and the Kinetic Wardrobe.

Welch describes the presentation as a warm-up to Arthur Brown’s Kingdom Come before the Alice Cooper Group appeared.

ARTHUR BROWN’S KINGDOM COME

THE SUPPORT PERFORMANCE

WELCH APPROVES

Welch is considerably more positive about Arthur Brown’s Kingdom Come.

The group’s performance is described as enjoyable, funny and inventive, providing a sharp contrast with the reaction to the headlining Alice Cooper Group.

A BETTER BAND THAN EXPECTED

KINGDOM COME

DRUMS & LEAD GUITAR

Welch admits that Kingdom Come were substantially better than expected.

Particular praise is given to the drummer and lead guitarist.

JOE’S LIGHTS

THE VISUAL SHOW

MOBILE BRAINS

The support presentation included lighting and visual effects associated with Joe’s Lights.

Welch also notes Roger Spear’s giant mobile brains among the barrage of stage ideas and props surrounding Kingdom Come.

THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE TWO ACTS

KINGDOM COME

ALICE COOPER GROUP

Welch finds Kingdom Come inventive and amusing even though the elaborate ideas apparently have limited effect upon the audience.

The Alice Cooper Group produces the opposite result: Welch dislikes the spectacle intensely, yet the audience responds with considerably greater enthusiasm.

PACKAGING

AMERICAN INDUSTRY

WELCH’S ARGUMENT

The review concludes by moving beyond individual songs or musicians and attacking what Welch regards as the packaging surrounding Alice Cooper.

America’s ability to package and advertise becomes the metaphor through which the reviewer interprets the entire show.

GIFT-WRAPPED EMPTINESS

THE CAPTION

THE FINAL VERDICT

Beneath the large performance photograph appears the devastating caption“ALICE COOPER: gift-wrapped emptiness”.

Welch’s concluding paragraph develops exactly that argument, presenting the Alice Cooper Group as the ultimate example of packaging overwhelming substance.

“BUY NOW”

THE ADVERTISING METAPHOR

A BITTER CONCLUSION

Welch deliberately writes the final lines in the language of sales and advertising.

The review closes by warning that, unlike an unwanted commercial product, the audience cannot obtain a refund for its values.

THE PHOTOGRAPH

A LARGE PERFORMANCE IMAGE

STAGE EFFECTS

A substantial monochrome concert photograph occupies most of the right side of the page.

Smoke or theatrical effects dominate the area behind the stage performers, visually reinforcing the spectacle Welch criticises in the adjoining text.

THE ORIGINAL ALICE COOPER GROUP

THE BAND

1971

This concert belongs to the original Alice Cooper Group era rather than Alice Cooper’s later solo career.

The Chronicle therefore preserves the act as the Alice Cooper Group while using “Alice Cooper” where the source itself refers specifically to the stage character or performer.

THE DOCUMENTED SET

SURVIVING RECORDING

ARCHIVAL CAUTION

An unofficial recording attributed to the November 7 Rainbow performance documents material including “Sun Arise”, “Caught in a Dream”, “I’m Eighteen”, “Halo of Flies”, “Second Coming”, “Ballad of Dwight Fry”, “Black Juju” and “Return of the Spiders”.

Because this track listing comes from a later unofficial release rather than Welch’s original review, it should remain identified separately and not be presented as though Melody Maker printed a complete setlist.

WHAT THE REVIEW DOCUMENTS

ALICE COOPER GROUP

ARTHUR BROWN / KINGDOM COME

Rainbow Theatre



Audience enthusiasm



Energetic playing



Excellent light show



Snake



Straitjacket



Theatrical provocation



Welch’s severe criticism

Roger Spear and the Kinetic Wardrobe



Arthur Brown’s Kingdom Come



Joe’s Lights



Mobile brain props



Inventive presentation



Positive critical response

CONTEXT AND NOTES

HISTORICAL CONTEXT

ARCHIVAL SIGNIFICANCE

Melody Maker published Welch’s review on November 13, 1971, following the Alice Cooper Group’s November 7 Rainbow Theatre appearance. Contemporary advertising confirms the Rainbow bill with Arthur Brown’s Kingdom Come.

The review should be preserved precisely because it is so hostile. It documents one influential British critic encountering the Alice Cooper Group’s combination of rock and shock theatre and rejecting much of it outright, even while recognising the audience response and energy of the musicians.

Welch’s opinion should not be softened retrospectively simply because the Alice Cooper Group subsequently became historically important.

That criticism is itself part of the historical record. The mismatch between Welch’s reaction and the packed audience’s enthusiasm makes the source considerably more revealing than an uncomplicated rave review.

The surviving unofficial live recording provides additional information about the concert repertoire but is separate evidence from the contemporary Melody Maker review.

Keeping the two forms of evidence distinct maintains archival accuracy: Welch tells us what the contemporary critic thought, while the later recording documents music associated with the performance.

CONCLUSION

ALICE’S MOVING PERFORMANCE

THE VALUE OF A HOSTILE REVIEW

Chris Welch’s headline begins with sarcasm and the review never backs away from its hostility. Snakes, straitjackets, theatrical mockery and the surrounding packaging leave the critic deeply unimpressed, even though the lighting, musical energy and audience enthusiasm occasionally break through.

For the archive, that makes the article particularly valuable. Historical documentation is strongest when it preserves disagreement as well as acclaim. The Rainbow audience appears to have embraced much of what Welch rejected, leaving “Alice’s Moving Performance” as a vivid contemporary record of just how divisive the original Alice Cooper Group could still be in Britain during 1971.

SOURCES / COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE

SOURCES

Melody Maker

November 13, 1971

Chris Welch

Original supplied Melody Maker review

Alice Cooper eChive

Rainbow Theatre concert documentation


COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE

All magazine scans, photographs, artwork and original text excerpts referenced in this entry remain the property of their respective copyright holders. This Chronicle entry is a transformative, non-commercial archival summary created for historical documentation and educational reference. No ownership of the original material is claimed or implied.


Comments


bottom of page