David Bowie (November 12, 1977) – “Who Was That (Un)masked Man?” Feature - NME
Updated: 2 days ago
NME |
Four years after their previous encounter, Charles Shaar Murray meets David Bowie again and finds a dramatically different figure from the extravagant Ziggy Stardust period. In a wide-ranging interview, Bowie discusses “Heroes”, Low, Berlin, Brian Eno, Japan, solitude, identity, technology, punk, past controversies and the continuing process of artistic change. |
FEATURE | DETAILS |
Artist: | David Bowie |
Publication: | New Musical Express |
Publication Date: | November 12, 1977 |
Writer: | Charles Shaar Murray |
Headline: | Who Was That (Un)masked Man? |
Cover Line: | The Phantom Stranger plays “Hide and Seek” |
Feature Pages Supplied: | 38, 39, 42 |
Photography: | Pennie Smith |
Principal Albums Discussed: | “Heroes” / Low |
Principal Location Discussed: | Berlin |
Format: | Cover Feature / Interview |
Principal Theme: | Bowie reflects upon identity, recent records, Berlin and life after the elaborate personae of earlier years |
ORIGINAL SOURCE MATERIAL
COVER | PAGE 38 |
[NME, NOVEMBER 12, 1977 – DAVID BOWIE COVER] ![]() | [PAGE 38 – OPENING FEATURE PHOTOGRAPH] ![]() |
PAGE 39 | PAGE 42 |
![]() [PAGE 39 – “WHO WAS THAT (UN)MASKED MAN?”] | ![]() [PAGE 42 – FEATURE CONTINUATION] |
INTRODUCTION
FOUR YEARS LATER | A VERY DIFFERENT DAVID BOWIE |
Charles Shaar Murray begins by remembering his previous encounter with Bowie four years earlier. That meeting belonged to the Ziggy era, when Bowie existed inside an extravagant world of conspicuous clothes, famous acquaintances and elaborate presentation. | In 1977, Murray encounters something very different. The surrounding circus has disappeared, the visual presentation is deliberately restrained and Bowie appears without an obvious new character announcing itself before the conversation even begins. |
THE COVER
DAVID BOWIE | THE PHANTOM STRANGER |
Bowie dominates the November 12 cover in a large monochrome portrait, with DAVID BOWIE printed across the image in striking red lettering. | Beneath the photograph appears the teasing cover line “The Phantom Stranger plays ‘Hide and Seek’”, immediately introducing the issue’s fascination with Bowie’s identity. |
WHO WAS THAT (UN)MASKED MAN?
THE HEADLINE | THE QUESTION BEHIND IT |
Murray’s headline plays upon Bowie’s long history of characters, images and deliberately constructed public identities. | The difference in 1977 is that the interviewer appears to be looking for Bowie after the masks have been removed rather than attempting to identify the latest one. |
THE DORCHESTER
THEN | NOW |
Murray remembers the earlier Dorchester encounter as a crowded and theatrical occasion surrounded by figures associated with Bowie’s Ziggy-era world. | Four years later, Bowie is presented in comparatively quiet surroundings, providing Murray with an immediate visual demonstration of how radically circumstances had changed. |
WITHOUT THE CIRCUS
THE EARLIER ENTOURAGE | TRAVELLING DIFFERENTLY |
Bowie’s previous environment had included musicians, associates and the elaborate machinery surrounding the Ziggy phenomenon. | By 1977, Murray describes Bowie as travelling much more simply and quietly. The absence of the entourage becomes one of the feature’s strongest symbols of change. |
“HEROES”
WHY THE QUOTATION MARKS? | IRONY |
Murray quickly asks why the title “Heroes” appears inside quotation marks. | Bowie explains that the punctuation introduces irony into the idea of heroism associated with the title song rather than simply celebrating a conventional heroic ideal. |
THE COUPLE BY THE WALL
HANSA | THE IMAGE BEHIND THE SONG |
Bowie describes the proximity of the Berlin Wall to the studio and what could be seen from the control room. | A couple meeting near the Wall supplied the imaginative starting point from which Bowie developed the ironic situation underlying “Heroes”. |
HANSA BY THE WALL
THE STUDIO | RECORDING ON AN EDGE |
The physical location of the studio becomes important to Murray’s questions about the atmosphere surrounding the album. | Bowie agrees with the suggestion that working so close to the Wall created a genuine sensation of being positioned on the edge of something. |
NOT A CONCEPT ALBUM
THE TITLE | THE COLLECTION |
Bowie resists the idea that “Heroes” should be understood as one unified concept simply because the album carries a striking title. | Instead, the record is presented as a collection of work assembled through collaboration and experimentation, with the strongest completed material forming the finished album. |
ROBERT FRIPP
THE COLLABORATION | THE FINISHED RECORD |
Robert Fripp appears within Bowie’s discussion of the musicians involved in the sessions. | His contribution forms part of the collaborative studio environment Bowie describes when explaining how the current album was assembled. |
BRIAN ENO
THE WORKING RELATIONSHIP | TEXTURE & IDEAS |
Brian Eno occupies a particularly important position within the discussion of Bowie’s recent work. | Bowie talks about Eno in terms extending beyond conventional instrumental ability, emphasising ideas, textures and approaches that could be applied across different musical situations. |
LOW
THE PREVIOUS RECORD | A PERSONAL PERIOD |
Murray repeatedly returns to Low, allowing the conversation to connect Bowie’s current work with the album that immediately preceded “Heroes”. | Bowie’s discussion links portions of Low strongly with the personal circumstances surrounding that period of his life. |
ALWAYS CRASHING IN THE SAME CAR
A PERSONAL SONG | THE FIRST SIDE OF LOW |
“Always Crashing in the Same Car” enters the conversation as an example of material rooted in Bowie’s own situation. | The discussion helps distinguish the more personal song-based material from some of the increasingly abstract textures occupying other parts of Low. |
ENO’S TEXTURES
THE SECOND SIDE | A DIFFERENT MUSICAL SPACE |
The instrumental side of Low leads naturally into further discussion of Eno. | Bowie values the textures created during the sessions while considering how those textures operate within the wider context of the album. |
EXPERIMENTATION
DISCOVERY | REFOCUSING |
The interview repeatedly describes the recent records in terms of experimentation rather than a settled formula. | For Bowie, discovery appears to be part of the creative goal itself. The process is presented as a refocusing of musical interests rather than an attempt to recreate an earlier commercial identity. |
BERLIN
LIVING ALONE | A CHANGED ENVIRONMENT |
Berlin occupies a central position within Bowie’s discussion of recent life as well as recent music. | Being alone in a comparatively unfamiliar environment is initially presented as difficult, but that isolation also becomes part of the circumstances surrounding a changed creative outlook. |
THE FIRST MONTHS
AN UNFAMILIAR EXPERIENCE | ADJUSTMENT |
Bowie discusses how unusual it was initially to live without the structures and distractions that had surrounded much of his earlier career. | Over time, the unfamiliarity itself becomes productive, allowing different ways of observing places, people and everyday life. |
JAPAN
A CONTINUING FASCINATION | KYOTO |
Bowie speaks at length about Japan and the attraction the country holds for him. | Kyoto features within the discussion as Bowie considers architecture, culture and experiences substantially removed from the conventional rock-tour environment. |
TRADITION & MODERNITY
JAPAN | BOWIE’S INTEREST |
The interview explores Bowie’s fascination with the relationship between Japanese traditions and modern life. | Bowie is attracted to the coexistence of very old cultural structures with contemporary technology and urban development. |
TRAVEL
WITHOUT AN ENTOURAGE | OBSERVATION |
Bowie talks about travelling in a much less elaborate way than during earlier periods of his career. | Walking through unfamiliar places and observing everyday surroundings becomes part of the changed rhythm of life Murray finds in 1977. |
BLACKOUT
THE QUESTION | NO SIMPLE EXPLANATION |
Murray asks about “Blackout” and whether the song carries a specific meaning. | Bowie is reluctant to reduce the recording to a single definitive interpretation, reflecting the broader interview’s resistance to neat explanations. |
READING
LITERATURE | IDEAS BEYOND MUSIC |
The conversation frequently moves away from recording into literature, ideas and cultural influences. | This makes the feature markedly different from a straightforward promotional interview built entirely around songs and forthcoming releases. |
IDENTITY
WHO IS DAVID BOWIE? | NO NEW MASK REQUIRED |
Murray’s comparison between the person interviewed in the Ziggy period and Bowie in 1977 creates a persistent question about identity. | The quieter presentation does not reveal one simple “real Bowie”. Instead, the interview suggests that abandoning obvious personae produces another set of questions rather than resolving them. |
THE UNMASKED MAN
THE TITLE’S JOKE | A MORE COMPLEX PERSON |
“Unmasked” could imply that removing the characters should expose a straightforward person underneath. | Murray’s discussion suggests almost the opposite. Without the spectacular masks, Bowie appears no easier to reduce to one fixed identity. |
PUNK
THE NEW MOVEMENT | BOUNDARIES |
Murray raises punk and the rapidly changing British rock environment of 1977. | Bowie shows interest while remaining wary of movements that impose restrictive definitions upon themselves and their participants. |
TECHNOLOGY
RAPID CHANGE | THE ORDINARY PERSON |
One of the interview’s more unusual subjects is technological change. | Bowie considers the speed with which ordinary people are expected to absorb new technology, sometimes before fully understanding the developments that preceded it. |
THE FOUNTAIN PEN
A SIMPLE ANSWER | DRY HUMOUR |
When asked to identify a recent technological innovation he understands, Bowie offers the deliberately mundane example of the fountain pen. | The answer undercuts the seriousness of the surrounding discussion and provides one of several examples of understated humour running through the conversation. |
PAST CONTROVERSIES
1976 | LOOKING BACK |
Murray does not avoid the controversy surrounding remarks attributed to Bowie during the previous year. | Bowie considers how theatrical observations and deliberately provocative statements could rebound once removed from the circumstances in which they were made. |
FASCISM
THE QUESTION | BOWIE’S RESPONSE |
Murray asks directly whether Bowie believed he had been misrepresented over comments associated with fascism. | Bowie accepts responsibility for having made remarks that could produce such consequences rather than treating the entire controversy simply as something invented by others. |
MISTAKES
A DIRECT ADMISSION | MOVING FORWARD |
Asked whether the episode had been a mistake, Bowie agrees that it was. | The wider point is that mistakes are presented as an inevitable consequence of continuing to move and experiment rather than remaining permanently within safe boundaries. |
LONDON
RETURNING HOME | WRITING AGAIN |
Towards the end, Murray asks whether London might again become creatively stimulating for Bowie. | Bowie considers the possibility that spending time away has changed the way familiar places appear when revisited. |
MARC BOLAN
A RECENT PASSING | A PERSONAL SUBJECT |
The final page brings Marc Bolan into the conversation. | Bolan’s passing was still extremely recent when the interview appeared, giving this portion of the discussion a particular contemporary weight. |
GERMAN MOTORIK & KRAFTWERK
CONTINENTAL EUROPE | CURRENT INTERESTS |
Bowie discusses musical relationships and influences extending beyond Britain and America. | German music and the wider European environment form another strand within the interview’s continuing exploration of changing creative interests. |
THE PENNIE SMITH PHOTOGRAPHS
PAGE 38 | PAGE 42 |
The opening photograph shows Bowie beside a window, the image divided dramatically between light and darkness. | Another substantial image on page 42 is credited to Pennie Smith and retains the same deliberately understated, intimate quality. |
THE VISUAL LANGUAGE
NO GLITTER | SHADOW & ORDINARY CLOTHING |
Nothing in the supplied feature photography attempts to recreate the overwhelming colour and spectacle associated with Ziggy Stardust. | Checked clothing, window light, heavy shadow and confined interiors visually reinforce Murray’s central argument about an apparently unmasked Bowie. |
THE NME COVER
NOVEMBER 12, 1977 | DAVID BOWIE |
Bowie dominates the front cover with both hands raised across much of the face. | The pose provides a perfect visual introduction to “Who Was That (Un)masked Man?”, simultaneously revealing and obscuring the cover subject. |
WHAT THE FEATURE DOCUMENTS
THE MUSIC | THE PERSON & IDEAS |
“Heroes” Low Hansa Berlin Brian Eno Robert Fripp “Blackout” Recent experimentation | Identity Solitude Japan Travel Literature Punk Technology Past controversy Mistakes London Marc Bolan |
CONTEXT AND NOTES
HISTORICAL CONTEXT | ARCHIVAL SIGNIFICANCE |
The feature appeared in the November 12, 1977 edition of New Musical Express, shortly after the release of “Heroes”. Charles Shaar Murray had interviewed Bowie four years earlier and consciously structures the article around the extraordinary difference between the two encounters. | That first-hand comparison gives the interview unusual value. Murray does not have to reconstruct the Ziggy era retrospectively because Murray had personally encountered Bowie within that earlier environment. |
The discussion ranges much further than “Heroes” itself, encompassing Low, Berlin, Eno, Japan, literature, punk, technology, mistakes and the nature of identity. | The supplied cover and feature pages also form a strong visual archive. Cover photography, the large page 38 image, Pennie Smith’s photograph and the sprawling typography all reinforce the interview’s concern with hiding, revealing and reconstructing Bowie. |
Some later transcriptions of the article have circulated with conflicting dates. The supplied physical issue is clearly dated November 12, 1977, and that date has therefore been retained. | The original source takes precedence over later transcription metadata when establishing the archive chronology. |
CONCLUSION
WHO WAS THAT (UN)MASKED MAN? | A BOWIE WITHOUT AN OBVIOUS CHARACTER |
Murray’s deliberately playful title conceals an unusually thoughtful interview. Bowie talks about records, places, other musicians and new ideas, but repeatedly returns indirectly to the question of what remains when familiar identities and circumstances are stripped away. | Four years after the extravagant Ziggy encounter, the circus has disappeared. Yet Murray does not discover a simple individual underneath. The Bowie of 1977 appears quieter and less theatrical, but also more difficult to define, making “Who Was That (Un)masked Man?” one of the most revealing contemporary documents of this period. |
SOURCES / COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE |
SOURCES New Musical Express November 12, 1977 Charles Shaar Murray Original supplied NME cover and feature pages Rock’s Backpages COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE All magazine scans, photographs, artwork and original text excerpts referenced in this entry remain the property of their respective copyright holders. This Chronicle entry is a transformative, non-commercial archival summary created for historical documentation and educational reference. No ownership of the original material is claimed or implied. |









Comments