David Bowie (November 5, 1972) – “Bowie: Now Or Later?” American Concert Review - Seattle Post-Intelligencer
Updated: 2 days ago
SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER |
Published in the Seattle Post-Intelligencer on November 5, 1972, Patrick MacDonald’s “Bowie: Now or Later?” examines David Bowie during the first major wave of American publicity surrounding Bowie and The Spiders from Mars. The article begins provocatively, asking whether Bowie really was becoming “the biggest hype job in rock ’n’ roll since every Mothers Son”, before describing a campaign in which advertisements, lengthy newspaper pieces and organised press activity had placed Bowie firmly in front of American music writers. |
FEATURE HIGHLIGHTS
FEATURE | DETAILS |
Artist: | David Bowie / The Spiders from Mars |
Publication: | Seattle Post-Intelligencer |
Date: | November 5, 1972 |
Location: | Seattle, Washington |
Writer: | Patrick MacDonald |
Headline: | “Bowie: Now or Later?” |
Venue: | Paramount Northwest |
Performance: | Previous Wednesday night |
Format: | Concert review / commentary |
Principal Theme: | The contrast between Bowie’s enormous publicity campaign and the reality of the Seattle performance |
ORIGINAL SOURCE MATERIAL
ORIGINAL SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER AMERICAN CONCERT REVIEW |
![]() [IMAGE – SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER, NOVEMBER 5, 1972 – DAVID BOWIE / “BOWIE: NOW OR LATER?”] |
INTRODUCTION
MacDonald’s eventual judgement is considerably more interesting than either outright dismissal or unquestioning praise. The Seattle appearance does not fully deliver the outrageous spectacle promised by the advance publicity, and the writer suggests that some expecting a more extreme show may have been disappointed. | Yet MacDonald also concludes that Bowie as an artist possessed genuine substance. Beneath the hype, the reviewer finds strong songs, capable musicians and enough originality to suggest that Bowie would remain important after the immediate publicity frenzy had passed. |
THE HYPE
THE PUBLICITY MACHINE | THE MUSICIAN BENEATH IT |
MacDonald describes a substantial RCA Records promotional campaign surrounding Bowie. The newspaper writer refers to advertisements, extensive press coverage and a heavy promotional effort aimed at establishing Bowie in America. The impression is deliberately overwhelming: American music journalists had been exposed repeatedly to claims that Bowie represented something important and new. | The central question is whether the artist underneath that campaign justified the attention. MacDonald does not simply reject Bowie because of the publicity. Instead, the reviewer separates the marketing from the performance and ultimately decides that, despite the excess surrounding Bowie’s introduction to America, there was genuine musical ability beneath it. |
THE SEATTLE CONCERT
THE ATTENDANCE | THE PERFORMANCE |
The article reports that barely 300 tickets had been sold two days before the Paramount Northwest concert, with only a last-minute radio and publicity effort helping to fill the venue. That detail provides a striking contrast with the huge amount of publicity MacDonald describes elsewhere in the article. | Against that uncertain commercial background, Bowie and the band performed a show MacDonald characterises as comparatively restrained when measured against the advance reputation. The controversial and sexually provocative image surrounding Bowie did not translate into the kind of continuous stage spectacle some audience members may have expected. |
The Seattle date therefore captures Bowie at a point when American press attention was running ahead of proven ticket demand in that particular city. | For the reviewer, that gap between expectation and reality becomes one of the central themes of the article. |
THE PUBLIC IMAGE
SEXUAL AMBIGUITY | PUBLICITY & PERFORMANCE |
MacDonald discusses contemporary publicity surrounding Bowie’s sexuality and refers to the British press coverage that had helped create an intentionally ambiguous public image. The article notes that the idea had been readily accepted in Britain and associated Bowie publicly with other prominent rock personalities. | The Seattle writer treats that imagery as part of the promotional phenomenon rather than allowing sexuality to become the complete explanation for Bowie’s appeal. The performance itself is judged separately, with MacDonald ultimately concentrating upon the music, songs and abilities of the band. |
THE STAGE PRESENTATION
WHAT WAS EXPECTED | WHAT SEATTLE SAW |
The promotional image surrounding Bowie had encouraged expectations of an extraordinarily provocative performance. MacDonald suggests that audience members anticipating something dramatically confrontational may have been disappointed by the relative restraint of the Seattle show. | Bowie did wear form-fitting, sequinned clothing and changed outfits during the performance, while painted fingernails and the highly stylised visual presentation remained visible. Yet the reviewer compares the actual stage behaviour with much more conventional show-business performers rather than describing the concert as an endless exercise in shock. |
The gap is significant because it reveals how Bowie’s reputation could arrive in a city before the live act itself had been experienced locally. | The concert therefore enables MacDonald to test the publicity directly rather than simply reporting it second-hand. |
THE SONGS
MATERIAL MENTIONED | THE MUSICAL IMPRESSION |
MacDonald identifies songs including “Andy Warhol,” “Life on Mars?,” “My Way” and material from Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars. The article notes Bowie’s interest in subjects ranging across city life, love, movies and fashion. | The reviewer regards Bowie as a capable songwriter and performer, describing individuality in the material rather than treating the songs as merely vehicles for the image. Poetry and parody are both identified as elements within Bowie’s writing. |
The varied subject matter gives MacDonald evidence that there is more to Bowie than the publicity concept surrounding the tour. | This becomes increasingly important as the article moves towards its favourable conclusion. |
THE SPIDERS FROM MARS
MICK RONSON | THE RHYTHM SECTION |
Mick Ronson receives particular praise. MacDonald identifies Ronson as guitarist and describes the performance as consistently strong, making Ronson one of the clearest musical assets within the review. | Mick Woodmansey on drums and Trevor Bolder on bass are described as competent, though MacDonald gives Ronson greater individual emphasis. Together they provide the instrumental foundation for Bowie’s performance. |
Ronson is also mentioned in connection with arrangements, reinforcing the importance of the guitarist within the live presentation. | The review therefore considers the concert as a band performance rather than treating Bowie’s backing musicians as anonymous support. |
DAVID BOWIE V DAVID CASSIDY
THE COMPARISON | MACDONALD’S VERDICT |
The article draws a deliberately sharp distinction between David Bowie and Cassidy. MacDonald argues that behind the publicity surrounding Bowie there is something substantial, while placing Cassidy on the opposite side of that comparison. | MacDonald’s point is that Bowie possesses genuine artistic ability independent of the promotion. The comparison is bluntly expressed in the original article, reflecting the contemporary gulf the writer perceived between manufactured pop celebrity and Bowie’s songwriting and performance. |
A SHOW STILL DEVELOPING
THE CURRENT PERFORMANCE | WHAT MIGHT COME NEXT |
MacDonald describes the latter portion of the Seattle show as comparatively mild, including a short semi-acoustic section featuring Bowie on 12-string guitar. That restrained musical passage sits awkwardly against the extravagant advance image but gives the reviewer another opportunity to judge the songwriting itself. | The conclusion looks beyond the immediate “drag-rock syndrome” surrounding Bowie. MacDonald suggests that Bowie was capable of moving beyond current trends and writing increasingly interesting material in the future. The prediction is cautious, but clearly favourable. |
THE PHOTOGRAPH
VISUAL PRESENTATION | PAGE CONTEXT |
A monochrome photograph captioned “David Bowie” appears beside the article. The seated figure is presented informally rather than through one of the more theatrical stage images associated with the Ziggy Stardust period. | The review occupies the left side of a broader newspaper entertainment page surrounded by advertisements for cinemas, theatres and adult entertainment. This situates the Bowie review within general Sunday entertainment coverage rather than a specialist music publication. |
CONTEXT AND NOTES
HISTORICAL CONTEXT | ARCHIVAL SIGNIFICANCE |
The article captures a fascinating stage in Bowie’s American development. RCA’s publicity was already substantial, but the Seattle ticket-sales figure reported by MacDonald indicates that widespread American concert recognition could not simply be assumed. Bowie was being sold as a major new phenomenon while still having to convince local audiences city by city. | That tension makes this more valuable than a straightforward positive concert review. MacDonald begins from a position of suspicion towards the publicity surrounding Bowie but ends by distinguishing the promotion from the artist. The performance itself persuades the reviewer that the songs and musicianship possess enough substance to survive beyond the immediate image campaign. |
The discussion of sexuality and fashion also provides direct evidence of how Bowie’s public identity was being interpreted by American regional newspapers in late 1972. | Equally important is the attention given to Mick Ronson, Trevor Bolder and Mick Woodmansey, preserving the Spiders from Mars as an identifiable working band rather than simply background to Bowie. |
CONCLUSION
THE REVIEW IN RETROSPECT | ARCHIVAL SIGNIFICANCE |
“Bowie: Now or Later?” is built around a simple question: once the extraordinary publicity is stripped away, is anything worthwhile left? Patrick MacDonald’s answer is essentially yes. The Seattle performance may not have fulfilled every expectation generated by RCA’s promotional campaign, but the reviewer hears strong songwriting, sees capable musicianship and finds enough originality to believe that Bowie’s future will extend beyond the current image. | For the archive, the cutting is an excellent contemporary American snapshot because nothing is yet inevitable. Bowie’s later status cannot influence the reviewer: ticket sales are uncertain, the image is controversial, and the American audience is still being won. MacDonald’s eventual confidence therefore matters. It records an American critic moving from scepticism about the hype towards recognition that David Bowie himself might genuinely be worth the attention. |
SOURCES / COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE |
SOURCES Seattle Post-Intelligencer, Seattle, Washington, November 5, 1972. “Bowie: Now or Later?” by Patrick MacDonald. COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE All magazine scans, newspaper cuttings, photographs, and original text excerpts referenced in this entry remain the property of their respective copyright holders. This Chronicle entry is a transformative, non-commercial archival summary created for historical documentation and educational reference. No ownership of the original material is claimed or implied. |






Comments