top of page

David Essex (November 5, 1975) – “No Spirit At The Roxy” Concert Review - Los Angeles Herald Examiner

Nov 5, 1975
7 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

LOS ANGELES HERALD EXAMINER

Published in the Los Angeles Herald Examiner on November 5, 1975, Robert Kemnitz’s “No Spirit At The Roxy” is a notably tough assessment of David Essex in concert at The Roxy. The writer begins by contrasting the performance with Stardust, arguing that David Essex had demonstrated enough sensitivity, talent and charisma on film to suggest genuine star potential. Faced with the live show, however, Robert Kemnitz concludes that acting the part of a rock

FEATURE HIGHLIGHTS

FEATURE

DETAILS

Artist:

David Essex

Publication:

Los Angeles Herald Examiner

Date:

November 5, 1975

Location:

Los Angeles, California

Writer:

Robert Kemnitz

Headline:

“No Spirit At The Roxy”

Venue:

The Roxy

Format:

Concert review

Film Referenced:

Stardust

Principal Theme:

A talented performer struggling to convince the reviewer as a rock artist

ORIGINAL SOURCE MATERIAL

ORIGINAL LOS ANGELES HERALD EXAMINER CONCERT REVIEW

David Essex – “No Spirit At The Roxy” Concert Review, Los Angeles Herald Examiner, November 5, 1975

[IMAGE – LOS ANGELES HERALD EXAMINER, NOVEMBER 5, 1975 – DAVID ESSEX / “NO SPIRIT AT THE ROXY”]

INTRODUCTION

performer and convincingly embodying one on stage were very different things.


The criticism is blunt but not wholly dismissive. Robert Kemnitz repeatedly acknowledges that David Essex possessed talent and could be a compelling singer. The problem, in the reviewer's view, is how that talent was being directed.

Rather than finding a distinctive rock identity, the performance appeared to borrow from several established stars, while much of the material struck the critic as too safe and middle-of-the-road. The accompanying band, sound system and stage effects receive considerably warmer treatment.

STARDUST V THE ROXY

THE ACTOR

THE ROCK PERFORMER

Robert Kemnitz begins with Stardust, arguing that David Essex had convincingly portrayed the rise and fall of a British rock superstar. The film performance is cited as evidence of genuine acting ability, sensitivity and charisma.

The Roxy performance leads the reviewer to a much harsher conclusion. Robert Kemnitz writes that the concert demonstrated that “you can’t act out rock ’n’ roll”, arguing that successful rock performance must appear instinctive rather than constructed.

This contrast provides the framework for the entire review.

The writer therefore judges the concert not only by the music but by whether the stage presence feels authentic.

ROCK NEEDS SPIRIT

THE CRITIC’S ARGUMENT

DAVID ESSEX AT THE ROXY

The article describes rock as “a spirit which cloys or turns sour when you let tricks take over most of its trade.” For Robert Kemnitz, theatrical technique alone cannot create convincing rock ’n’ roll.

The reviewer considers David Essex overly calculated during much of the performance. The criticism is less about technical competence than about the sense that the performer was working too visibly at creating the desired effect.

The headline “No Spirit At The Roxy” grows directly from this argument.

Even where talent is acknowledged, the performance is judged as lacking the natural quality the writer expects from rock.

BRITISH POPULARITY

SUCCESS AT HOME

THE AMERICAN RESPONSE

The article acknowledges David Essex’s enormous popularity in Britain, describing appearances capable of generating extremely intense audience reactions. The single “Hold Me Close” is identified as a major British hit.

Robert Kemnitz contrasts that success with the much colder reception encountered at The Roxy. An American club crowd, according to the review, provided a very different test from an enthusiastic British teenage audience.

The writer uses British success as evidence that David Essex clearly possessed significant popular appeal.

The review simultaneously refuses to treat overseas popularity as proof that the Roxy performance worked.

A HARSH VIEW OF THE BRITISH CHARTS

THE COMMENT

THE CONTEXT

Robert Kemnitz offers a deliberately caustic aside about British record buyers, suggesting that many contemporary British hits were excessively slick, excessively loud or lacking in sophistication.

The comment helps explain the critic’s scepticism towards using British chart success as evidence of artistic quality. It is clearly the reviewer’s opinion rather than a factual judgement about British popular music.

This is one of the cutting’s more confrontational passages.

For the archive, preserving it matters because it records an American critic’s contemporary response without retrospectively softening the hostility.

THE TEENYBOPPER QUESTION

THE AUDIENCE

THE REVIEWER’S DISTINCTION

The writer argues that British teenage audiences were famous for intense and sometimes indiscriminate enthusiasm. The Bay City Rollers are used as a deliberately negative example.

Robert Kemnitz believes David Essex had more genuine talent than that comparison might imply. The problem was not an absence of ability, but the reviewer’s belief that David Essex had not yet learned where and how to use it most effectively.

The discussion is highly opinionated and reflects the tone of the original critic.

This distinction prevents the review from becoming a simple dismissal of David Essex as another teen idol.

SEARCHING FOR A STAGE IDENTITY

THE COMPARISONS

THE CRITICISM

The review compares elements of David Essex’s performance with several established entertainers, including Rod Stewart, Leo Sayer, Roger Daltrey and Anthony Newley.

Rather than interpreting those references as versatility, Robert Kemnitz sees indecision. The reviewer argues that David Essex appears uncertain about precisely what kind of stage performer to become.

Mick Jagger is invoked as another reference point for rock performance.

The repeated comparisons underpin the writer's view that a more distinctive identity still needed to emerge.

THE VOCAL TALENT

WHAT WORKS

WHAT DOESN’T

Despite the severity of the review, Robert Kemnitz explicitly states that David Essex’s voice “can be compelling.” This is an important qualification to the headline and surrounding criticism.

The writer believes much of the material does not allow that voice to reach its full potential, describing the music overall as sitting safely within the middle of the road.

Talent is therefore never really the issue.

The criticism concerns repertoire, presentation and the direction in which that talent is being channelled.

THE BAND

NINE-PIECE BAND

VOCAL TRIO

David Essex’s nine-piece group receives strong praise from the critic. The band is described as a “very snug fit” on the Roxy stage, but the remark is physical rather than musical criticism.

The vocal trio is included within the positive assessment of the accompanying musicians.

Unlike the reservations surrounding the star’s performance, the musical support is not portrayed as a weakness.

The size of the ensemble also helps distinguish the concert from a stripped-back conventional rock-band format.

SOUND & THEATRICS

THE SOUND SYSTEM

THE SMOKE MACHINE

Robert Kemnitz reports that the sound system was excellent and functioned properly throughout the entire performance.

The smoke machine also worked exactly as intended, producing dramatic clouds on cue. The reviewer calls it “a smooth theatrical breeze all the way.”

This positive technical assessment is significant because it removes poor sound as an explanation for the critic’s dissatisfaction.

The theatrical machinery succeeds technically even though the reviewer remains unconvinced by the underlying rock performance.

SEE THE MAN STANDING IN THE SHADOWS

THE SONG

THE REVIEW’S CLOSING THOUGHT

The article closes by referring to David Essex singing “See the man standing in the shadows, he looks a lot like me.”

Robert Kemnitz turns the line into a metaphor for the entire concert, suggesting that the real rock ’n’ roll side of David Essex might still be waiting to emerge.

The song lyric provides the critic with a more thoughtful ending after the harsher comparisons earlier in the article.

Crucially, the reviewer does not conclude that the potential is absent, only that the Roxy performance had not fully revealed it.

THE PHOTOGRAPH

IMAGE

CAPTION

A large monochrome close portrait appears within the left column of the review. The image occupies a substantial portion of the article and gives David Essex a strong visual presence despite the negative tone of the text.

The original caption reads “David Essex . . . acting too hard”, directly reinforcing Robert Kemnitz’s central criticism.

The photograph and caption therefore form part of the review's argument rather than serving as neutral illustration.

The visual presentation leaves little ambiguity about the newspaper's overall judgement.

CONTEXT AND NOTES

HISTORICAL CONTEXT

ARCHIVAL SIGNIFICANCE

The cutting captures David Essex confronting the difficulty of translating significant British pop success into a convincing American rock-club performance. Britain's increasingly enthusiastic young audience and a comparatively cool Roxy crowd represented very different environments in which to test the same performer.

The review is valuable precisely because it is critical. Robert Kemnitz finds genuine ability in David Essex, praises the voice, backing musicians and technical production, but remains unconvinced by the stage identity and repertoire. Preserving that mixture produces a far more useful historical document than reducing the article to either praise or hostility.

The numerous comparisons with established performers also demonstrate how an American critic attempted to categorise David Essex for local readers in 1975.

The cutting should therefore remain intact rather than having its negative passages softened. It documents one contemporary reaction to an artist working to establish a position beyond the British teen-pop audience.

CONCLUSION

THE REVIEW IN RETROSPECT

ARCHIVAL SIGNIFICANCE

“No Spirit At The Roxy” sounds devastating, but the article underneath is more nuanced. Robert Kemnitz believes David Essex possesses talent, charisma and a potentially compelling voice. The criticism is directed at a concert the writer considers overworked, stylistically uncertain and supported by material that rarely matches the performer's abilities.

The final suggestion that a stronger rock identity might still emerge is therefore important. The Roxy show fails to convince this particular critic, but David Essex is not dismissed as talentless. For the archive, that tension makes the review particularly worthwhile: it records an American writer wrestling with the difference between British pop-idol success, theatrical presentation and what the writer personally considered authentic rock ’n’ roll.

SOURCES / COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE

SOURCES

Los Angeles Herald Examiner, Los Angeles, California, November 5, 1975.

“No Spirit At The Roxy” by Robert Kemnitz.


COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE

All magazine scans, newspaper cuttings, photographs, and original text excerpts referenced in this entry remain the property of their respective copyright holders. This Chronicle entry is a transformative, non-commercial archival summary created for historical documentation and educational reference. No ownership of the original material is claimed or implied.


Comments


bottom of page