top of page

Bubblegum (November 20, 1971) – “Bubblegum Is Here to Stay” Feature

Nov 20, 1971
9 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

MELODY MAKER

Melody Maker examines why bubblegum pop continued to flourish despite its poor reputation among more serious rock listeners. Using comments from hit songwriter Nicky Chinn, Sweet singer Brian Connolly and Middle of the Road guitarist Ian Lewis, the feature considers simple melodies, young audiences, dancing, commercial success and the difficulty of defining where clever pop ends and disposable bubblegum begins.

FEATURE HIGHLIGHTS

FEATURE

DETAILS

Publication:

Melody Maker

Publication Date:

November 20, 1971

Page:

13

Headline:

Bubblegum Is Here to Stay

Principal Contributors:

Nicky Chinn, Brian Connolly, Ian Lewis

Groups Represented:

Sweet / Middle of the Road

Other Artists Mentioned:

Bay City Rollers, Jonathan King, The Beatles, Jimmy Young, The Archies, T. Rex, The Tremeloes

Songs Mentioned:

Co-Co, Sugar Sugar, Yummy Yummy Yummy, She Loves You, Please Please Me, I Want to Hold Your Hand

Format:

Music-Trend Feature / Artist Commentary

Principal Theme:

Why simple, melodic and danceable bubblegum records continued to achieve commercial success

ORIGINAL SOURCE MATERIAL

ORIGINAL MELODY MAKER FEATURE


Bubblegum – “Bubblegum Is Here to Stay” Feature, November 20, 1971 – Melody Maker, November 20, 1971 – “bubblegum Is Here To Stay” – Page 13

[MELODY MAKER, NOVEMBER 20, 1971 – “BUBBLEGUM IS HERE TO STAY” – PAGE 13]

INTRODUCTION

BUBBLEGUM IS HERE TO STAY

A COMMERCIAL CONSTANT

Melody Maker opens with the argument that styles may change, groups may disappear and charts may alter from week to week, but bubblegum records continue to sell.

The feature deliberately contrasts commercial popularity with critical respectability, noting that a successful bubblegum single could outperform records regarded as more intellectually respectable.

WHAT IS BUBBLEGUM?

SIMPLE POP

A DIFFICULT LABEL

The article treats bubblegum as music built around immediacy, uncomplicated melodies and accessibility.

Yet the contributors do not agree completely over what deserves the label, demonstrating how easily “bubblegum” could become either a useful description or a dismissive insult.

THE MARKET

VERY YOUNG

VERY OLD

Melody Maker argues that bubblegum could appeal at both ends of the age spectrum.

Children form an obvious market, but the article also suggests that older listeners respond to uncomplicated tunes that can easily be remembered, whistled or sung.

SWEET

A CURRENT SUCCESS STORY

YOUNG LISTENERS

Sweet are presented as one of the strongest contemporary examples of a group benefiting from the bubblegum market.

The article notes the particular appeal the group held for school-age listeners.

NICKY CHINN

SONGWRITER

SWEET’S HITS

Nicky Chinn is introduced as a composer responsible for two successful Sweet singles.

Chinn provides one of the feature’s clearest defences of bubblegum, arguing that good examples are happy, accessible records rather than inherently inferior music.

CO-CO

A SWEET HIT

BUBBLEGUM DISCUSSION

“Co-Co” is named as one of the recent successes associated with Sweet.

Its inclusion places the discussion firmly within the current British pop market rather than presenting bubblegum purely as an American phenomenon from earlier years.

HAPPY MUSIC

NICKY CHINN’S VIEW

PEOPLE ENJOY IT

Chinn characterises bubblegum as happy music.

For Chinn, enjoyment and immediate appeal are strengths rather than evidence that a record lacks musical value.

PROGRESSIVE MUSIC

A DIFFERENT PURPOSE

NOT ALWAYS ACCESSIBLE

Chinn contrasts bubblegum with progressive music.

The argument is not simply that one is better than the other, but that simple pop can reach listeners who have little interest in more complex musical forms.

EASY TO IDENTIFY WITH

MELODY

SING-ALONG APPEAL

Chinn says bubblegum is easy for listeners to identify with.

Simplicity makes a tune easy to whistle or sing, giving the music an immediate social quality beyond critical analysis.

KIDS

THE PRINCIPAL AUDIENCE

AGES FOUR TO SIXTEEN

Chinn identifies young listeners as the core audience.

The article describes the market as including children across a broad age range, while also acknowledging that adults may enjoy the same simple melodies.

NOT FOR EVERYONE

OLDER YOUNG LISTENERS

A DIFFERENT TASTE

Chinn does not claim that bubblegum appeals equally to everybody.

The feature suggests that listeners in their later teens and early twenties may be less attracted to music so directly identified with younger audiences.

GOOD BUBBLEGUM & BAD BUBBLEGUM

THE IMPORTANT DISTINCTION

QUALITY STILL MATTERS

Chinn strongly rejects the idea that all bubblegum is automatically good simply because it is catchy.

The feature acknowledges a large amount of poor material, but argues that the existence of bad records does not invalidate the best examples of the style.

GETTING BETTER

EARLIER RECORDS

IMPROVED PRODUCTION

Chinn believes bubblegum had improved considerably.

In Chinn’s view, some earlier examples were comparatively rough, whereas newer records were becoming much better made.

GOOD TO DANCE TO

THE DISCOTHEQUE

PHYSICAL APPEAL

Dancing is presented as another reason for bubblegum’s durability.

The article notes that the style had always been played in discotheques because its direct beat and melodic immediacy worked effectively on the dance floor.

SUGAR SUGAR

THE ARCHIES

A DEFINING EXAMPLE

“Sugar Sugar” by The Archies is singled out as one of the greatest bubblegum records.

The selection provides the feature with a clear example against which the contributors measure other recordings.

YUMMY YUMMY YUMMY

ANOTHER CLASSIC EXAMPLE

THE FORMULA

“Yummy Yummy Yummy” is also mentioned as a major bubblegum record.

Together with “Sugar Sugar”, it represents the immediately memorable American pop sound strongly associated with the term.

T. REX

ALMOST BUBBLEGUM

AN INTERESTING CONTEMPORARY VIEW

T. Rex receive a particularly interesting passing assessment within the feature.

The article records the view that T. Rex are almost bubblegum these days, describing the sound as a kind of heavy bubblegum.

HEAVY BUBBLEGUM

T. REX

A USEFUL 1971 DESCRIPTION

The phrase acknowledges the directness and simplicity of T. Rex’s enormously successful singles.

At the same time, adding heavy distinguishes Bolan’s electric rock sound from the lighter records conventionally associated with bubblegum.

WHY THE T. REX REFERENCE MATTERS

NOVEMBER 1971

CONTEMPORARY CLASSIFICATION

The T. Rex remark appears while the group’s transformation into a major British singles act was still unfolding.

It provides a useful contemporary example of critics and fellow musicians trying to find terminology for Bolan’s increasingly direct and commercially powerful pop-rock sound.

THE EARLY BEATLES

BUBBLEGUM IN RETROSPECT?

FAMILIAR HITS

Melody Maker argues that some early Beatles records might have been classified as bubblegum had they been released in 1971.

The suggestion deliberately challenges the idea that the label can be applied neatly according to artistic reputation.

SHE LOVES YOU

THE BEATLES

A SIMPLE POP CLASSIC

“She Loves You” is one of the early Beatles hits cited in the discussion.

Its melodic simplicity and immediate appeal are used to question where commercially accessible pop should be separated from bubblegum.

PLEASE PLEASE ME

ANOTHER BEATLES EXAMPLE

THE LABEL QUESTIONED

“Please Please Me” is also included.

The article uses such celebrated records to suggest that the traits associated with bubblegum can exist within music later regarded much more seriously.

I WANT TO HOLD YOUR HAND

DIRECTNESS

A POP SONG BUILT TO CONNECT

“I Want to Hold Your Hand” completes the Beatles examples specifically named.

Again, Melody Maker challenges readers to consider whether simplicity itself deserves to be treated as artistic weakness.

JIMMY YOUNG

AN OLDER AUDIENCE

THE MARKET EXTENDS BEYOND TEENAGERS

Jimmy Young’s listeners are mentioned as another potential market for accessible records.

This supports the feature’s opening argument that bubblegum need not belong exclusively to young teenagers.

BRIAN CONNOLLY

SWEET

A SINGER’S VIEW

Sweet singer Brian Connolly provides another perspective on the genre.

Connolly sees bubblegum’s simplicity as central to its broad appeal.

UP TO SIXTEEN

SWEET’S AUDIENCE

SIMPLE MUSIC

Connolly says bubblegum particularly appeals to people up to the age of sixteen.

The reason offered is straightforward: the music is uncomplicated and consequently easy to understand and enjoy.

MUMS & DADS

ADULT LISTENERS

MELODY STILL WORKS

Connolly also believes adults respond to simple melodies.

Parents may find themselves singing along and then buying the records, extending Sweet’s audience beyond the school-age listeners most obviously associated with the group.

THIRTEEN AND FOURTEEN

A CONSTANT NEW AUDIENCE

WHY BUBBLEGUM SURVIVES

Connolly points to the continual arrival of young listeners around thirteen and fourteen.

As long as new teenagers enter the record-buying market, there will be an audience for clever, direct pop music.

DO FANS WANT LIVE SHOWS?

THE RECORD FIRST

THE GROUP LATER

The article asks whether bubblegum audiences actually care about seeing performers live.

Connolly believes fans initially buy the record regardless of who performs it, but repeated hits gradually create curiosity about the group itself.

THE RECORD BEFORE THE GROUP

A POP-MARKET PATTERN

THE TREMELOES

Connolly argues that bubblegum audiences can become interested in performers only after discovering the records.

The Tremeloes are cited as an example of the record initially coming before the public image of the group.

FACES AFTER HITS

RECOGNITION

PERSONALITY DEVELOPS LATER

According to Connolly, repeated hit records eventually make the performers themselves recognisable.

Commercial success can therefore transform anonymous-sounding pop into a personality-led fan relationship.

IAN LEWIS

MIDDLE OF THE ROAD

REJECTING THE LABEL

Guitarist Ian Lewis provides the most direct disagreement within the feature.

Lewis does not accept that Middle of the Road should be described as a bubblegum group.

COMMERCIAL POP BAND

MIDDLE OF THE ROAD’S DESCRIPTION

A DIFFERENT POSITION

Lewis instead calls the group a commercial pop band.

The distinction is important because it demonstrates how negatively the bubblegum tag could be perceived even by musicians working successfully in highly accessible pop.

A MIDDLE POSITION

THE GROUP NAME

THE MUSICAL PHILOSOPHY

Lewis says Middle of the Road are taking exactly that: a middle position.

The group seeks strong melodies and commercial appeal without accepting the suggestion that the music lacks substance.

NO MEANING?

LEWIS DISAGREES

MUSIC CAN STILL HAVE VALUE

Lewis describes some repetitive chorus lines as lacking meaning.

Yet Middle of the Road’s own intention, according to the guitarist, is to develop commercially attractive music without reducing everything to formula.

COMPETENT MUSICIANSHIP

PROFESSIONAL PLAYING

PROGRESSIVE MUSICIANS

Lewis argues that professional musicians must be competent regardless of musical style.

Interestingly, Lewis also says musicians playing progressive music are generally better players, adding another layer to the feature’s continuing tension between commercial appeal and musical complexity.

THE THREE CONTRIBUTORS

NICKY CHINN / BRIAN CONNOLLY

IAN LEWIS

Chinn and Connolly broadly accept bubblegum as a valid form of simple, effective commercial pop.

Lewis is much less comfortable with the term and rejects its application to Middle of the Road.

THE THREE PORTRAITS

CENTRAL IMAGE STRIP

CHINN / LEWIS / CONNOLLY

Three monochrome portraits are stacked vertically through the centre of the page.

The printed caption identifies the subjects as Nicky Chinn / Ian Lewis / Brian Connelly, visually linking the three principal voices in the debate.

THE PAGE DESIGN

BUBBLEGUM

IS HERE TO STAY

Bubblegum appears in enormous curved black lettering across the top.

The words “is here to stay” are arranged vertically beneath it in equally bold type, transforming the central argument into the page’s dominant graphic element.

THE BORDER

BLACK CIRCLES

FULL-PAGE FRAME

Repeated black circular shapes form a border around almost the entire feature.

The playful graphic frame suits an article discussing a pop style built around simplicity, repetition and immediate visual impact.

WHAT THE FEATURE DOCUMENTS

WHY BUBBLEGUM WORKS

WHY THE LABEL IS DIFFICULT

Simple melodies



Easy identification



Young audiences



Adult sing-along appeal



Dancing



Commercial success



Repeated hit records



Fan interest developing after the record

Bad bubblegum versus good bubblegum



Progressive music comparisons



Early Beatles songs used as examples



T. Rex described as “heavy bubblegum”



Middle of the Road rejecting the label



Commercial pop versus musical complexity

CONTEXT AND NOTES

HISTORICAL CONTEXT

ARCHIVAL SIGNIFICANCE

Melody Maker published “Bubblegum Is Here to Stay” on November 20, 1971, bringing together views from songwriter Nicky Chinn, Sweet singer Brian Connolly and Middle of the Road guitarist Ian Lewis.

The article is particularly useful because the term bubblegum is being debated by people actively working inside the contemporary pop market rather than defined retrospectively decades later.

Sweet and Middle of the Road are central to the discussion, while The Archies, The Beatles, Jimmy Young, The Tremeloes and T. Rex provide reference points.

Those comparisons demonstrate how broadly the term could be applied and why some musicians welcomed the description while others rejected it.

The description of T. Rex as almost bubblegum, specifically “a sort of heavy bubblegum”, is a contemporary opinion contained directly within the supplied article.

For the T. Rex archive, the phrase is particularly useful evidence of how Bolan’s increasingly direct hit-making sound was being discussed by contemporaries during the breakthrough period.

CONCLUSION

BUBBLEGUM IS HERE TO STAY

SIMPLE DOES NOT NECESSARILY MEAN EASY

Melody Maker’s November 1971 feature asks a deceptively complicated question: if millions of people enjoy direct melodies, danceable rhythms and uncomplicated songs, why should those qualities automatically make a record worthless? Nicky Chinn and Brian Connolly largely defend the form, while Ian Lewis resists having Middle of the Road placed inside it.

The most revealing aspect is how uncertain the boundaries are. Early Beatles hits can retrospectively look like bubblegum, Sweet can embrace simplicity, and T. Rex can be described as “heavy bubblegum” while sounding unlike The Archies. The article therefore preserves not simply a pop trend, but an argument about commercial music, taste and credibility that was taking place in real time.

SOURCES / COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE

SOURCES

Melody Maker

November 20, 1971

Page 13

Original supplied Melody Maker feature page


COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE


All magazine scans, photographs, artwork and original text excerpts referenced in this entry remain the property of their respective copyright holders. This Chronicle entry is a transformative, non-commercial archival summary created for historical documentation and educational reference. No ownership of the original material is claimed or implied.


Comments


bottom of page