top of page

The Spiders From Mars (November 15, 1975) – “Black Man White Man” Single Review

Nov 15, 1975
7 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

UNIDENTIFIED UK MUSIC PRESS

A spectacularly hostile contemporary review greets The Spiders From Mars’ “Black Man White Man” with faint praise for Trevor Bolder’s powerful bass playing before demolishing almost everything else about the record. The critic describes the single as so poor that it should “file bankruptcy papers” and dismisses the songwriting by concluding that a less promising debut would have been “scientifically impossible”. Preserved alongside the November 15 release Chronicle, the cutting provides an uncompromising contemporary reaction to the post-Bowie Spiders attempting to establish a recording identity of their own.

FEATURE HIGHLIGHTS

FEATURE

DETAILS

Artist:

The Spiders From Mars

Publication:

Unidentified UK Music Press

Publication Date:

November 15, 1975

Single:

Black Man White Man

Label:

Pye

Principal Member Mentioned:

Trevor Bolder

Name Variation Mentioned:

Boulder

Positive Comment:

Bolder’s bass playing

Overall Verdict:

Extremely negative

Songwriting Comment:

Critical of the two new Spiders

Format:

Contemporary Single Review

Archive Status:

Publication still to be positively identified

Principal Theme:

A severe contemporary assessment of The Spiders From Mars’ new record

ORIGINAL SOURCE MATERIAL

ORIGINAL CONTEMPORARY REVIEW CUTTING

The Spiders From Mars – “Black Man White Man” single review cutting, November 15, 1975

[IMAGE – THE SPIDERS FROM MARS – “BLACK MAN WHITE MAN” SINGLE REVIEW – NOVEMBER 15, 1975]

INTRODUCTION

BLACK MAN WHITE MAN

A BRUTAL CONTEMPORARY VERDICT

The surviving November 15, 1975 review gives “Black Man White Man” one of the harshest critical receptions imaginable.

Trevor Bolder receives acknowledgement for the strength of the bass playing, but that brief compliment is immediately overwhelmed by an extraordinarily severe assessment of the record as a whole.

THE SPIDERS FROM MARS

THE ARTIST CREDIT

POST-BOWIE IDENTITY

The review identifies the act directly as The Spiders From Mars.

The record belonged to the period in which musicians associated with the Spiders name were attempting to establish a recording identity separate from their earlier role alongside David Bowie.

BLACK MAN WHITE MAN

THE SINGLE

PYE

The reviewed record is “Black Man White Man”.

The cutting identifies the label directly as Pye.

TREVOR BOLDER

BASS

THE ONE CLEAR COMPLIMENT

Trevor Bolder receives the only substantial piece of praise in the short review.

The critic describes the bass as “remarkably sturdy”, acknowledging the effectiveness of Bolder’s playing even while rejecting the record around it.

“BOULDER”

AN UNUSUAL SPELLING

THE REVIEWER COMMENTS

The cutting refers to Trevor Bolder with a parenthetical observation about the spelling “Boulder”.

The reviewer suggests that this was apparently how Bolder then wished to be known, preserving an unusual contemporary detail within the review.

GOOD BASS PLAYING

A POSITIVE START

IMMEDIATELY UNDERCUT

The critic accepts that the bass performance is good.

The compliment lasts only briefly before the reviewer argues that even strong bass playing cannot rescue a fundamentally poor record.

“GOOD BASS PLAYING ALONE…”

THE ARGUMENT

ONE MUSICIAN CANNOT SAVE IT

The reviewer argues that accomplished bass playing has rarely been sufficient to save an otherwise unsuccessful record.

“Black Man White Man” is then presented as an especially extreme example of exactly that problem.

THE VERDICT TURNS SAVAGE

FROM PRAISE

TO TOTAL REJECTION

Bolder’s playing gives the review a momentary positive foothold.

From that point onwards, virtually every judgement becomes strongly negative.

“SO POOR…”

THE REVIEWER’S LANGUAGE

NO ATTEMPT TO SOFTEN IT

The critic describes the record as extraordinarily poor.

The wording deliberately exaggerates the commercial consequences of that judgement for comic impact.

“FILE BANKRUPTCY PAPERS”

THE MOST MEMORABLE LINE

A DEVASTATING PUT-DOWN

The reviewer says the record is so poor that it should “file bankruptcy papers”.

The line makes the cutting particularly memorable and leaves no ambiguity about the critic’s reaction.

THE SONGWRITING

THE TWO NEW SPIDERS

ANOTHER TARGET

The review states that the song was written by “the two new Spiders”.

Their writing is criticised as heavily as the finished recording.

A MORE PROMISING DEBUT

WHAT MIGHT HAVE BEEN

THE REVIEWER’S VIEW

The critic argues that the two new members could have organised a more promising debut.

This criticism makes the review about more than performance or production; the underlying composition itself is considered unsuccessful.

“SCIENTIFICALLY IMPOSSIBLE”

THE CLOSING LINE

NO REDEMPTION

The review ends with an even more dismissive joke.

The critic states that “one less promising would have been scientifically impossible.”

THE COMPLETE CRITICAL TRAJECTORY

BEGINNING

ENDING

Trevor Bolder plays remarkably sturdy bass.

The record is judged so unpromising that, according to the critic, producing anything less promising would be scientifically impossible.

A VERY SHORT REVIEW

FEW WORDS

MAXIMUM IMPACT

The surviving cutting occupies only a small amount of space.

Yet the extremity of its language gives it considerably greater archival interest than many much longer but less distinctive contemporary reviews.

NO AMBIGUITY

NOT MIXED

NOT LUKEWARM

This is not a review requiring complicated interpretation to determine whether the critic liked the record.

Aside from Bolder’s bass, the assessment is overwhelmingly and deliberately hostile.

WHY WE SHOULD NOT SOFTEN IT

ARCHIVAL HONESTY

CONTEMPORARY OPINION

The purpose of the archive is to document how records and artists were actually received at the time.

Rewriting the criticism into something more sympathetic would remove precisely what makes the source historically useful.

THE CRITIC MAY HAVE BEEN WRONG OR RIGHT

THAT IS NOT THE POINT

THE REACTION IS THE EVIDENCE

A later listener is free to disagree completely with the review.

What matters archivally is that this was one contemporary critical response to the record in November 1975.

THE RELEASE & THE REVIEW

THE SINGLE CHRONICLE

THE REVIEW CHRONICLE

The November 15 release entry documents “Black Man White Man” as a record: artist, format, label and its place within The Spiders From Mars chronology.

This companion entry documents reception, preserving what one unidentified UK critic actually thought of the record at the time.

TWO DIFFERENT ARCHIVAL FUNCTIONS

RELEASE HISTORY

RECEPTION HISTORY

Release documentation establishes that the record existed, when it appeared and how it was marketed.

A review tells us something entirely different: how the recording sounded to a contemporary listener encountering it as new music.

AFTER DAVID BOWIE

THE SPIDERS NAME

AN UNAVOIDABLE SHADOW

The Spiders From Mars name carried substantial history into any subsequent recording project.

A new record therefore had to function not only as music in its own right but as evidence that the name could support a viable identity beyond its celebrated earlier association.

A DIFFICULT EXPECTATION

THE FAMILIAR NAME

NEW MATERIAL

Audiences already knew The Spiders From Mars through an established musical history.

New material inevitably invited judgement over whether the group could create something convincing under that name in a new context.

TREVOR BOLDER’S BASS

THE REVIEW’S SAVING GRACE

PERSONAL MUSICIANSHIP

Importantly, the critic does not dismiss every element indiscriminately.

Bolder’s sturdy bass playing is specifically separated from the reviewer’s negative assessment of the song and record.

PERFORMANCE VERSUS MATERIAL

BOLDER

THE SONG

The bass performance demonstrates musicianship the critic considers worthy of acknowledgement.

The composition surrounding that performance is regarded as fundamentally inadequate.

THE UNKNOWN PUBLICATION

WHAT WE KNOW

WHAT WE DO NOT KNOW

The cutting is filed in the archive as November 15, 1975, and the text clearly identifies The Spiders From Mars, “Black Man White Man”, Pye and Trevor Bolder.

The cropped source does not preserve the publication masthead, reviewer’s name or other identifying material sufficient to attribute the review securely to a particular UK music publication.

WHY WE ARE NOT GUESSING

MELODY MAKER?

NME? SOUNDS? RECORD MIRROR?

Several UK music papers could plausibly have carried contemporary singles reviews.

Without positive evidence from the full page, assigning one of those publications would introduce an unsupported fact into the archive.

ARCHIVE STATUS

DATE

PUBLICATION

November 15, 1975 – retained from the original archive filing

Unidentified UK Music Press – awaiting positive identification

FUTURE IDENTIFICATION

IF THE COMPLETE PAGE IS FOUND

EASY TO UPDATE

A masthead, reviewer byline, neighbouring identifiable reviews or page number may eventually establish the source.

The Chronicle can then be updated immediately without altering the review content or its archival date.

WHAT THE CUTTING DOCUMENTS

THE RECORD

THE REVIEW

The Spiders From Mars



“Black Man White Man”



Pye



Trevor Bolder



“Boulder” name reference



New Spiders songwriting

“Remarkably sturdy bass”



Good bass unable to save the record



“File bankruptcy papers” criticism



Songwriting heavily criticised



Debut judged unpromising



“Scientifically impossible” closing dismissal

CONTEXT AND NOTES

HISTORICAL CONTEXT

ARCHIVAL SIGNIFICANCE

The original cutting has been retained in the archive under November 15, 1975 and reviews The Spiders From Mars’ “Black Man White Man” on Pye.

The date is preserved from the user’s original archive filing, while the publication remains deliberately unidentified until stronger documentary evidence becomes available.

Trevor Bolder’s bass playing receives direct praise before the reviewer attacks the record itself.

This distinction is worth preserving because the criticism is aimed principally at the quality of the single and songwriting rather than claiming that every musician involved performs badly.

The review twice resorts to deliberately exaggerated humour, first suggesting the record should file bankruptcy papers and finally declaring that a less promising debut would have been scientifically impossible.

These phrases capture the tone of the source and should remain part of the Chronicle rather than being sanitised into a mild retrospective description.

The review now sits alongside the existing November 15 release Chronicle.

Together, the two entries document both the record itself and one contemporary critical response, giving the November 15 archive considerably greater depth.

CONCLUSION

BLACK MAN WHITE MAN

A REVIEW WITH NO MERCY

The unidentified critic finds one thing to admire in “Black Man White Man”: Trevor Bolder’s remarkably sturdy bass. Everything surrounding it is treated with extraordinary hostility. The song is considered poor, the songwriting unpromising and the chances of producing a weaker debut jokingly dismissed as scientifically impossible.

That brutality is exactly why the clipping belongs in the archive. We have already documented the record’s release; this companion Chronicle preserves what happened when at least one contemporary critic actually listened to it. Positive or negative, that response forms part of the history of The Spiders From Mars and should remain exactly as candid as it was in November 1975.

SOURCES / COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE

SOURCES

Unidentified UK Music Press

November 15, 1975

Original supplied “Black Man White Man” review cutting

Original archive filing


COPYRIGHT & ARCHIVAL USE


All newspaper or magazine scans, record artwork and original text excerpts referenced in this entry remain the property of their respective copyright holders. This Chronicle entry is a transformative, non-commercial archival summary created for historical documentation and educational reference. No ownership of the original material is claimed or implied.


Comments


bottom of page